What are the similiarities and differences between Chi Sim and Hung Fa Yi Wing Chun?

[phantom]

Also, why are they commonly taught together? Thanks in advance.

[taltos]

I speak for neither lineage, but I can offer up some information.

They both have an extremely similar Kiuh Sau platform. They both have a "Heaven/Human/Earth" strategy/orientation. They both rely heavily on Chan philosophies in their tactical engine.

In application, I personally feel that Chi Sim appears (physically) to bear a stronger resemblance to "traditional" Shaolin, where Hung Fa Yi appears (physically) to bear a stronger resemblance to the upright orientation we know and expect from Wing Chun.

As far as I know, the two are only taught side by side in VTM Schools. That is a fairly recent development.

-Levi

[Savi]

Hey Phantom, a discussion with nearly the same thread name is over at HFY108.

HFY and Chi Sim Thread (http://www.hfy108.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=673)