PDA

View Full Version : Is this a lesson on reasoning?



Kennyfist
09-25-2005, 07:54 PM
Hsk
Quote:"now, if the both of them claim to be the only outsider in chan heungs camp, and both sides name these two as "the" most outstanding student of chan heung. it is kind of hard not to think that they are not one and the same

This is getting funny....

Now if A says Pete sampras is the most oustanding tennis player of the 20th century.... and B says Andre Aggassi is the most outstanding tennis player of the 20th century......

And both sides also claim BOTH ARE MEN and BOTH PLAY TENNIS and BOTH WERE ALIVE IN 20TH CENTURY quote: .""it is kind of hard not to think that they are not one and the same."


SO USING YOUR TYPE OF REASONING THEN PETE SAMPRAS = ANDRE AGASSI? WHAT KIND OF EVIDENCE IS THAT? WHAT KIND OF REASONING?

IS THAT THE WHOLE OF YOUR "RESEARCH" FOR YOUR JEONG AND LONG CLAIM?--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Kennyfist
09-25-2005, 07:58 PM
From another thread:

Hsk,
Are you contradicting yourself again?

Quote:"it is kind of hard not to think that they are not one and the same."