Once Upon A Time In China 2

[Black_Talon]

Is it any good? I love part one, Jet Li is awesome in it, even with the wire work!!!

------------------
Some may boast of prowess bold,
Of the school they think so grand,
But there's a Spirit, can ne'er be told,
It's the Spirit of Aggieland
------------------
------------------
UT Unlimited, your premier mapping site!
Ace82@unrealism.com
UT Unlimited (http://utu.unrealism.com)

[Lost_Disciple]

I've always like Part 2 better.
Thought part 1 was a bit slow, cuz I saw part 2 first.
No Yuen Biao tho, Tang Fung is played by a HK comedian, he's funnier at least.
I guess it depends on what of Part 1 that you liked, whether or not you'll like Part 2.
.

[Crimson Phoenix]

Part 2 is usually considered the best of the six OUATIC movies...indeed, it has more rythm and develops good caracters depth...plus Donnie Yen is awesome in it, as usual...I could watch the first brawl with staffs between him and jet all day long!!

Phoenix

[Black_Talon]

Cool, I guess I'll add OUATIC 2 to my next in line to buy DVD list :)

------------------
Some may boast of prowess bold,
Of the school they think so grand,
But there's a Spirit, can ne'er be told,
It's the Spirit of Aggieland
------------------
------------------
UT Unlimited, your premier mapping site!
Ace82@unrealism.com
UT Unlimited (http://utu.unrealism.com)

[EmptyCup]

part 1 had some pretty good fights in it but I'll always prefer part 2 as there are two major fights at the end. One with the lotus cult leader and one with Donny with poles. If you liked Once Upon a Time in China, be sure to check out another Wong Fei Hung movie starring Donny as well - Iron Monkey. The fights are not as good as those in OUATIC 1 & 2 but still "up there" in terms of quality.

Btw, did anyone notice that the screen shots from the back of Once Upon a Time in China 3 were actually from 2? :) I didn't like the third one, mostly because there was no hand-to-hand, one-on-one fight in the end but just a exaggerated lion-dance melee...

[Jimbo]

I agree that part 2 is the best of the series. I especially liked Jet Li's 2 fights against Donnie Yen. This movie seemed to have the best cinematography as well.

I hated parts 3 and 4. Part 5 was okay but IMO mainly because it was very different (it was copied in many ways by Shanghai Noon).
Jim

[Ky-Fi]

Well, I guess I'm in the minority here, as I preferred the first one. The plot, cinematography, acting and story were all great in part 2, but I felt it relied heavier on wires and speeded-up camera, and I didn't think the fights looked as good or as natural as they did in the first one. It's still a good movie, though.

"Without tradition, art is a flock of sheep without a shepherd; without innovation it is a corpse." --Sir Winston Churchill

[Design Sifu]

I liked Iron Monkey better....

[Black_Talon]

Thanks for the advice, I just bought OUATIC 2, so I'll watch it and let you know which one I like better!!

------------------
Some may boast of prowess bold,
Of the school they think so grand,
But there's a Spirit, can ne'er be told,
It's the Spirit of Aggieland
------------------
------------------
UT Unlimited, your premier mapping site!
Ace82@unrealism.com
UT Unlimited (http://utu.unrealism.com)

[wufupaul]

I agree that the first one was better, it didn't drag on as long. The whole White Lotus cult scenes just dragged on, it brought the movie down and made it kinda boring. I think the fights in the first one were better, too.

"Who is your daddy, and what does he do?"-Arnold Schwarzenegger

[Drunken Monkey]

dont get me wrong part two was good but the story to part one was much better.

[jethro]

not quite as good as 1, more action, but not quite as high of quality. The stick fight between yen and li is the only thing that compared to 1,s 5-6 fights. I still can't find iron-robe yim from the 1st in the 2nd one, can anybody tell me who he plays because imdb says shen yee-kwan is in # 2.

[GeneChing]

I think OUATIC1 vs. OUATIC2 (http://www.martialartsmart.net/dvd4003.html) is one of the most longstanding debates in kung fu films (although some would argue Kill Bill 1 vs. Kill Bill 2 is equally heated). I prefer OUATIC2 (and KB1).

[Shaolinlueb]

I liked 2 cause of the fight scene between jet and donnie. that was bad ass. kill bill 1 was so much better then kill bill 2

[jethro]

I liked 2 cause of the fight scene between jet and donnie. that was bad ass. kill bill 1 was so much better then kill bill 2


As in KB 2, that's all I wanted to say.

[GreenCloudCLF]

Man, someone went back and dredged up a 5 year old thread...that's weird...

I like OUATIC2 cause of the Yen man

I like the fight scenes in KB1 more...

But love the eye pluckingscene in KB2...mmmmm crane claw..

[Judge Pen]

OUATIC 2 by a hair.

Kill Bill 2 was a better over-all "film", but the action was so much better in KB1. Though, it's really unfair to compare them as they are really one movie. I'm looking forward to the long awaited "original cut" of Kill Bill so we can see how it all comes together as one film.

[Shaolinlueb]

Btw, did anyone notice that the screen shots from the back of Once Upon a Time in China 3 were actually from 2? :)


yeah i noticed that too. yeah they reversed the packaging. smart move there.

actually i liked 4 and 5. much better then i liked 3. never saw 6 really.

[Judge Pen]

3 stunk. I have the Once Upon a Time in China and America at home. Never watched it. Is it worth it?

[Shaolinlueb]

3 stunk. I have the Once Upon a Time in China and America at home. Never watched it. Is it worth it?

well sammo hung did the fight choreo if i remember correctly. so yeah those should be good.