PDA

View Full Version : Ip Man Movie : Which exact Ip Man lineage?



WCFighter
07-14-2010, 10:04 AM
Hi everyone,

Wow! A lot of bickering in this forum between different WC clans, and within the same clans; that's sad.


Anyhoo...


I know the movie's been out for a while, but which exact lineage of WC under Ip Man was shown?

(As most of us know, there are many different students of Ip Man and they all have their distinct way of expressing their wing chun)

Who did Sammo Hung (the directory) consult with for this movie?


P.S.

Best darn kung fu movie I have seen to date.

chusauli
07-14-2010, 10:45 AM
I believe they consulted with Yip (Ip) Chun.

anerlich
07-14-2010, 05:12 PM
Best darn kung fu movie I have seen to date.


IMO Fearless left it in the dust.

SergeTk
07-14-2010, 07:17 PM
IMO Fearless left it in the dust.

IMO Fist of Legend left fearless in the dust :D

anerlich
07-14-2010, 08:35 PM
IMO Ong Bak killed 'em all!:D

LSWCTN1
07-15-2010, 12:30 AM
Jiu Wan student Guy Lai for the first one, and i know that Cliff Au Yeung (wsl student) was certainly involved in the second

Niersun
07-18-2010, 09:06 AM
Best darn kung fu movie I have seen to date.

Its great the first time. Downhill from there.

The bickering is usually due to certain people taking cheap shots at other people Sifu's. Even though their own sifu is generations behind.

doug maverick
07-26-2010, 12:00 AM
Hi everyone,

Wow! A lot of bickering in this forum between different WC clans, and within the same clans; that's sad.


Anyhoo...


I know the movie's been out for a while, but which exact lineage of WC under Ip Man was shown?

(As most of us know, there are many different students of Ip Man and they all have their distinct way of expressing their wing chun)

Who did Sammo Hung (the directory) consult with for this movie?


P.S.

Best darn kung fu movie I have seen to date.

well in his previous wing chun films, prodigal son and warriors two...sammo was learning wing chun from leung ting. so i think he just relied on that.

doug maverick
07-26-2010, 12:03 AM
I believe they consulted with Yip (Ip) Chun.

yip chun was only the consultant as far as his fathers life was involved.