Hendrik
02-28-2014, 03:10 PM
Opinion :
Whatever the case, you do not need a deep understanding of Qi for wing chun development. All of this talk of Qi in wing chun is just someone taking ideas from other MA's and trying to fit them into their sometimes incomplete idea of WC.
Fact:
Wing chun kuen is a traditional Chinese martial art based on ancient Chinese culture. Qi is a non replaceable part of in depth ancient Chinese culture and martial art elements . Qi support the physical body development and the Jin development of Wck in its own unique way.
Without this part of element, Wck is partial with reference to traditional Chinese martial art.
Opinion:
Similar to someoone mixing in snake/crane 100 years ago to flush out their missing wc trining. Or, it's just an attempt to make themselves stand out and look unique.
Fact:
Wing chun kuen DNA across the trackable older red boat Wck lineages such as : YKS, Snake Crane, And Yik Kam, is a fusion of the Fujian White Crane and Emei 12 zhuang.
In contrary, It is the modern created wing chun kuen lineages , in the past few decades , which divert from Wck snake crane DNA.
By examine the SNT set signature of the particular lineage will confirm and verify the fact.
Opinion:
Ok, please share with us your results since you started adding accumpuncture and medicine ideas into your wing chun.
Fact:
Chinese medicine , Qi, accupuncture points and medirians are always a part of WCK within SNT set since the creation of SNT set . Because SNT is a creation of pre 1850, and it follows Chinese culture and traditional Chinese martial art technology at that era.
In contrary, It is the lack of these elements indicated a modern creation lineage , or a lineage which has lost this part of the traditional teaching.
Wck is an ancient Chinese design, certainly not a western Newtonian physics time space design. Thus, Wck is based on Chinese culture.
Opinion:
What proven increase in fighting abilities have you personally experienced?
While wing chun practice does have health benifits, that is just a bi-product of the training. There are also phylisophical benifits for self growth. And we can do chi gung outside of WC for health benifits.
But the main reason for the existence of wing chun is for combat. All the theory, EKG reports, old scrolls, etc do not prove the results. Without proven increase in combat skills, what are we even talking about?
Fact:
In Ancient traditional Chinese martial art, Qi, health, strengthen the body , force flow handling and combat applications are one big un separate piece.
It is those who is lack of a full understanding of ancient transitional Chinese martial art system , will then fail to see the facts of these elements within wing chun kuen.
Opinion:
Qi doesn't exist. It is non sense.
Fact:
One can always model Qi as a fusion of bio chemical and bio electrical element which influence the bio mechanical.
Qi can be lead to travel in the medirians to heal or unblock stagnation to get instant relief, such as when one twisted a joint or pull muscle or after take a strike.
Activate Qi medirians switching can cause the arm to feel light weight or heavier such as in chi sau or real life application.
These are some of Qi and medirians handling capability for those who has formal training in Qi in SNT.
There is no mysterious but all scientific.
Whatever the case, you do not need a deep understanding of Qi for wing chun development. All of this talk of Qi in wing chun is just someone taking ideas from other MA's and trying to fit them into their sometimes incomplete idea of WC.
Fact:
Wing chun kuen is a traditional Chinese martial art based on ancient Chinese culture. Qi is a non replaceable part of in depth ancient Chinese culture and martial art elements . Qi support the physical body development and the Jin development of Wck in its own unique way.
Without this part of element, Wck is partial with reference to traditional Chinese martial art.
Opinion:
Similar to someoone mixing in snake/crane 100 years ago to flush out their missing wc trining. Or, it's just an attempt to make themselves stand out and look unique.
Fact:
Wing chun kuen DNA across the trackable older red boat Wck lineages such as : YKS, Snake Crane, And Yik Kam, is a fusion of the Fujian White Crane and Emei 12 zhuang.
In contrary, It is the modern created wing chun kuen lineages , in the past few decades , which divert from Wck snake crane DNA.
By examine the SNT set signature of the particular lineage will confirm and verify the fact.
Opinion:
Ok, please share with us your results since you started adding accumpuncture and medicine ideas into your wing chun.
Fact:
Chinese medicine , Qi, accupuncture points and medirians are always a part of WCK within SNT set since the creation of SNT set . Because SNT is a creation of pre 1850, and it follows Chinese culture and traditional Chinese martial art technology at that era.
In contrary, It is the lack of these elements indicated a modern creation lineage , or a lineage which has lost this part of the traditional teaching.
Wck is an ancient Chinese design, certainly not a western Newtonian physics time space design. Thus, Wck is based on Chinese culture.
Opinion:
What proven increase in fighting abilities have you personally experienced?
While wing chun practice does have health benifits, that is just a bi-product of the training. There are also phylisophical benifits for self growth. And we can do chi gung outside of WC for health benifits.
But the main reason for the existence of wing chun is for combat. All the theory, EKG reports, old scrolls, etc do not prove the results. Without proven increase in combat skills, what are we even talking about?
Fact:
In Ancient traditional Chinese martial art, Qi, health, strengthen the body , force flow handling and combat applications are one big un separate piece.
It is those who is lack of a full understanding of ancient transitional Chinese martial art system , will then fail to see the facts of these elements within wing chun kuen.
Opinion:
Qi doesn't exist. It is non sense.
Fact:
One can always model Qi as a fusion of bio chemical and bio electrical element which influence the bio mechanical.
Qi can be lead to travel in the medirians to heal or unblock stagnation to get instant relief, such as when one twisted a joint or pull muscle or after take a strike.
Activate Qi medirians switching can cause the arm to feel light weight or heavier such as in chi sau or real life application.
These are some of Qi and medirians handling capability for those who has formal training in Qi in SNT.
There is no mysterious but all scientific.