Moshe- my comments in brackets embedded in your post:
[QUOTE=MOSHE;1126734]hello
fine to see regarding your precedent mail that you are progressing in your perception of the original wing chun
((Not exactly- just understanding Ng Chan's POV via your sifus writing)
i wish again to precise that these clips have no interest apart to show the precision of the flow of his movements (again like the ip man clips)
((All videos have limitations))
but they should not be educatives;
(Understood- but gives some insights on POV)))
about the movements themselves most are wrong like the precedents videos
((Most movements- deliberately wrong? Depending on experienced eyes- you can see things))
in fact ,this way to film people when they dont promote anything of their own drive non
warned watchers to a wrong practise on wing chun
((Videos are not the best way to learn- I did not learn via videos))
perhaps we should discuss about how people are reaching the level of mastering their art and to what this is really corresponding
((Me? By practicing as taught hands on and applying and experimenting=progressive experience))
what people are expecting ?
((Me? To learn wing chun well))
how they avaluate their sifu and on which basis ?
((Skill, knowledge, personal and teaching ability))
when i read that about very important details ,people are seeing them like not too much specials and that ignoring them will not change anything ,this is a bis error
((Some things can reinforce what I know))
this is due to a lack of experience and know how received from a real master
((My sigung was a very close student of Ip man and kept in touch with him even upto the day Ip man died))
((Again thanks for sharing. It's good to have a sense of Nf Chan wing chun. You may want to check the broad curriculum and dictionary of terms at:http://www.fongswingchun.com/
As Chee pointed out your sifu's writing is pretty compact- even comes out that way in translation.
Chee has done a good job because of his tacit knowledge of wing chun and the language skills))Joy Chaudhuri