Consider me to not have an instructor, merely comprehension
"How do you come to the conclusion that because of the tree training that he had to practice the push hands less? "
"Take two people, train both of them in the same method using the slow form and push hands etc. except with one of them you employee tree methods. Do this for a year. And bring them up against each other in push hands, which do you, think would win? "
No conclusion, they both trained for a year's time. One did two things. One did three things. The one who did tree methods would have spent less at at least one of the two things the other person was also doing.
"I can see that you DON'T KNOW!
I said TC is a conductor, not a builder.
Chi moves through the relaxed body, tension hinders the flow.
Common knowledge. "
Yet, you still haven't said to where it's conducted.
"Martial jing or power is aquierd through work. The slow form and push hands by itself will not develop this. If it was true, than why did Yang Cheng Fu practice (if I remember right) "Play the guitar
and Replulse the Monkey" with a 40 pound weight attached to his index finger by a string. this is the modern day master that created the form that most follow today( Yang style has the largest following)."
"Play the Guitar" and "Repulse the Monkey" are techniques in the forms. They for intents and purposes here count as form. Saying that a well known--famous, martial artist ( a great man) trained his form is still saying that, part of his being great came from doing Form.
"How do you come to the conclusion that because of the tree training that he had to practice the push hands less? How do you know that I'm talking about banging on the trees? "
You mentioned conditioning which suggests the hitting the tree. Hitting the tree does not suggest pushing hands with the tree.
"There are more methods for using a tree than just banging on.
the taoist Bear method is just one."
Yet with hitting methods being common with trees, you did not specify. It is acceptable to take what you;re saying at the more common understanding of tree methods.
" No, your wrong.
If I have more power with the same degree of sensitivity as you,
YOU WILL LOSE. "
T'ai Chi Ch'uan absorbs and nullifies power and deflects/redirects~force. You don't seem to be talking about the example now. If I'm appropriate, I would not lose.~
"If only for the fact that my root is going to be stronger than yours because of the tree training. My stronger root and sensitive hands allow me to do things you can't with out violating the principles. "
Because of the tree training It does not seem to be a fact that your root would be better (again you seem to be away from the case mentioned). Different perhaps, but not necessarily better.
"Simply making this statement "day, moment, place" is any fight.
Also it's avoiding the point being made. "
Placed in context, that satement addresses that there is more to your physical~ training to win. No avoiding a point. You might care to mentin what point you have in mind that I supposedly was trying to avoid.
"My strikes don't back you up, You just drop. "
According to you, My conditioning if good enough might not give you the drop me effect.
"This is the Internal and this is what we're talking about. "
"Your book theory is alright for the health nuts, but against some one like me....
You have a problem."
I had a book theory?
"Look, I know your style better than you do and thats bad considering it's not my specialty. Do more research and train alot harder. one day you might get a glance of what I'm talking about. "
You know My Style?
...A glimpse of Nothingness.