Originally Posted by
KPM
I don't imply I tell you straight .
Tell me what straight? So are you saying "straight" that Leung Jan taught an incomplete system in Ku Lo village and didn't transmit any "gong" training?
I have been asking you to visit Jim Rosalendo who has the system to see the kulo system.
And I have told you that I have and do study the Ku Lo system. You haven't. You don't seem to actually know much about it. We established that here already in the past threads. Jim was actually the one that pointed that out.
Why guessing?
Guessing about what? You aren't making any sense.
Also, argue is not going to make a incomplete sysyem complete. .
So you ARE saying Pin Sun Ku Lo Wing Chun is incomplete because it does not do the SNT form as a whole. You are saying that Leung Jan taught an incomplete system, meaning substandard, not good.
And purposely discount it is not going to make a complete system in complete
And just what the heck does that mean???
You still have not explained how the Yip Man or Yuen Kay Shan SNT form develops "gong"....even though each section is separated from the others and punctuated by drawing both hands back to the chest with a brief pause....any differently than if the same sections were broken out and practiced individually. Robert has mentioned the flow and transition between sections. But again, there is a brief pause as you return to "neutral" with the fists at the chest. So I am not seeing how there is any meaningful flow or transition there.
And you haven't demonstrated what this special "gong" you are referring to brings to the mix. People have asked you multiple times. Does it make one a better fighter? Does it make your Wing Chun more effective?
And while we are at it, Zuti was asking a very simple and legitimate question. Why can't you tell him which museum holds that Emei book that you have referred to so often? I doubt Jim will be crushed if you mention this before he does. It is a legitimate question.
I have been with you speaking out against unfair attacks and an obvious smear campaign. But you are starting to "push my buttons" again as well.