I really don't follow why so many make a big deal out of forms. It's agreed all around that they aren't required to learn to fight so if you don't like them or don't think they're useful then don't do them. If you think they help then keep practicing them.
I don't see how a personal belief/preference bothers others so much. Why should any of you care if I, or anyone else, use forms to help with fighting? Does it affect your training any?
Personally I think they're fun to do, can be done anytime anywhere with no need for equipment or a training partner. They break up the monotony of weight lifting and running etc. which I find very boring. I prefer working out with a partner but don't have one so I guess all I can do is "pretend".
What are you doing when hitting a heavy bag? Do you "pretend" you're hitting someone? Would it bother anyone if I followed the same pattern of moves when I work the bag? Maybe a couple of different sequences I use over and over?
Mix them up randomly sometimes if I'm in the mood to practice that way otherwise just go out and follow one of my routines when I'm tired but still want to get in the practice.
I mean what's the big deal?