Taiwanese Hung Gar (Hung Chuan)
This is in response to a previous post, where the validity of my Hung Gar teacher calling himself Shr Fu was questioned. Here's the history behind it.
Wong Fei-Hong had many students. We all know Lam Sai Wing and a few others, but there were many other students, some of which relocated to Taiwan prior to the Cultural Revolution. Hung gar continued to be taught there, although the names changed since Taiwan is a Mandarin speaking country. So Hung Gar became Hung Chuan, and that is what I learned.
There's an on-going debate as to which style is closest to what Wong Fei-Hong taught. Taiwanese teachers claim that Cantonese Hung Gar is a diluted version with elements from other styles added. Cantonese teachers claim that Hung Chuan is merely a "distant cousin" of the original Hung Gar. My opinion is that neither "style" is any closer to master Hong's kung-fu. Styles change over periods of time; some things get lost in the process. A good analogy is my accounting training; I learned relatively high levels of accounting practice, but the accounting I do now is totally different form what I've learned; because I've adapted it to fit my job and my style of work.
And that is just one lifetime; we're talking about several generations here. So in my opinion, there is no "one true" Hung Gar.
:cool:
Taiwan Hung Gar and Hung Men
We ran a two-part series on Taiwan Hung Men last year in our May June and July August issues. It was received quietly by the Hung Gar community here, probably because they're so Canton-centric. Also it was a bit of a heady piece, since you had to know about the Hung Men as well as Romance of the Three Kingdoms.
Anyway, our publisher Gigi Oh has just come back from Taiwan again, so there's more Taiwan Hung Gar in the queue. Watch the mag!
Taiwanese Hung gar (Hong Quan)
Here is some more info on Taiwanese Hung Gar Martial Arts
http://www.kungfuplano.com/Southern_Shaolin.html
There are some other Masters in the U.S.A. with English websites, most in Taiwan only have Chinese sites.