Less mystical talk and more sweat please
With all the ceremonies ,robe wearing head shaving, bead wearing and pretend righteousness it is easy to forget Shaolin is a kung fu system. Man there is so much bull**** that goes on my favorite expression has become[the only secret is sweat]. Anyway some of yesterdays training, waiting for all the so called experts to tell me how I'm not using the secret methods. Funny ever time I meet some new "Master" here they say the same thing. Every other school sucks and they know the real stuff then you see their 15 year old students perform some purely physical performance form. I'm not saying there isn't a higher level to kung fu but it is laid on thick and 90 percent of the mystical stuff is way overrated, I mean way over rated.Less talking more training from all the know it all masters out there would go a long way.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wByNZ0jIt-U
Are you there to teach or learn?
Hey Wiz cool c. What you speak of is the very essence and yes mystery of Shaolin Kung Fu. It’s not mystical but rather an undefined gray area. I can relate to you, being a practitioner myself of martial arts for the last 20+ years (gosh am I really that old now?!). I have trained and spent some time with at least 3 of the shaolin masters here in the Houston Texas area schools. I consider them good masters and friends.
What you will find, based on your post, is the majority of the Shaolin masters think similar to the teacher in your video. I personally have learned 1 shaolin hand form (Xiao Hong Quan) 3 different ways. Each master had a their own reasons for teaching it different and yes Sometimes there was the chatter of other masters teaching it wrong for xyz reasons.
What I have learned through years is Shaolin is the style that is always evolving. Forms don’t always remain the same. You won’t find a source there that will show you what real traditional shaolin is. The staff is one of the 18 traditional weapons of shaolin. Yes, not many people walk around with a staff or use it for fighting but you are going to learn it as pure tradition. It’s all a matter of interpretation if the form is high skill or low skill. Again, there is no definitive answer. For example, I couldn’t perform a staff form with the speed and power of a kid 20 years younger than me. Is the kid’s staff form a higher level than mine because of this? What if the kid is in a fight and all he has is a staff. If his mind is not trained to be in a full contact fight for his life the staff would be useless. It doesn’t mean his skill is any higher than mine. It just depends where his mind is.
As for the rest, the majority of shaolin masters and their schools will always claim to be better than the other. It’s the nature of the beast in Deng Feng. I chalk it up to the very competitive nature of the Chinese. The shaolin masters are human after all and not all of them want to live a monastic life. Kung Fu is schools are a business.