Quote:
Originally Posted by
JPinAZ
You know, you can just say "I don't know", it's a perfectly acceptable answer :)
And of course I'm confused - you are all over the place with your non-answers!
I do know..it depends on the person and the situation. Of course, you know this.
What's vague about saying many groups take too long to teach the curriculum?
Quote:
Yes, you are good at avoiding questions and not backing up your claims - I'm glad you are able to see that too!
Does make me wonder, how does one become an authority in what doesn't work, yet totally unable to explain what does....
I responded to the thread. You pretended I said something else. Not avoiding anything. Ask me whatever you like and I will answer
Quote:
Look, it's really simple. You've been pretty vocal about what doesn't work and even went a bit further with you formula for developing 'functional WC' (SNT, CK, Chi Sau, Dummy & Pole), why can't you tell long it takes?
It depends on the person and the training situation. 3 months is a sorter time than even the most gifted person can manage though.
Quote:
Hell, take a guess if you don't really know. I would think for someone to feel as strongly as you do about something, you could answer such a simple question rather easily. I mean, you do base your opinions on actual experience and not just guesses and theory right?
It's a stupid question
Quote:
I think most people that claim to be teaching WC would guess it should take an average person training every day at least a couple of years to go thru that material. And I argue that if it takes that long before WC starts to become functional, then they are doing something drastically wrong!
Lol
Quote:
Is that so? Eh, I guess you're right since you apparently haven't really said anything (as you even pointed out).
If I didn't say anything then what are you arguing about?
Quote:
Again, vague and more avoiding. Thanks for not sharing..
There is nothing evasive is stating that you need to follow the wing chun method to end up with wing chun. You can't put wing chun into a person via short cuts because it is a sequential method that builds upon what came before. If you miss bits you don't end up with wing chun