Quote:
Originally Posted by
zuti car
won several major Judo cometitions in his younger days , he has proven cometition record, unkile all people from VT, who have "underground ,secrets fights and they never lost "
Firstly, I don't make this claim, as I just made clear. So, you are arguing with yourself.
Secondly, Judo competition doesn't allow punching, kicking, or striking of any kind.
It has nothing to do with free fighting and is not comparable to street fighting at all.
Quote:
he was judo referee for years .
Also irrelevant.
Judo competition is not fighting.
Quote:
he is teaching genuine , complete and probably the oldest WCK style
"Complete" in the same way YKS WC is complete, by incorporating elements of internal styles?
Age of a style does not guarantee quality or even functionality, especially if untested.
Quote:
Money hungry "grandmasters" whose only qualification for the job was coule of months spent in Yip Man's school
True in most cases, whereas, Wayne's qualification is having competed in Judo? Irrelevant to fighting and his WC skill.
Quote:
You Know ,every time when I go to HK , Wayne never allows me to pay anything , everytime we go to have a lunch or a dinner he insists to pay , because I came to visit him.It is a small thing , but says alot about the man .
It only says that he's Chinese. That's their culture. Don't you live in Taiwan or something? Do you have any friends?
Even best friends who go out to eat every week, year after year will still fight over the bill every time.
You think a Chinese wouldn't feel ashamed to let a guest pay for their own meal? Face is the biggest thing to them.
Quote:
I visited many schools and level of explainiation and level of knowledge was in 99,9 % of the cases limited by lack of education and lack of intellleigence , in most cases , both , because professional grandmasers are only that .
You have not visited every school, or even every lineage.
Intelligence, yes, but education level doesn't make you a better fighter.
Many teenagers do quite well before even finishing high school.
I even know 5 year old girls who show better skills than Wayne.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
zuti car
I don't know who did you talk but YKS syle is complete and far more sophisticated than YM's style
Elements added from Taijiquan don't make it more "complete", and complexity doesn't make it more functional.
Quote:
and has everything YM style has it
It differs entirely in strategic approach, development process, and has no similarity in tactics.
They don't have anything non-superficial in common.
Quote:
,on the other hand YM's style is missing a lot things that can be found in YKS and other mainland styles.
Namely, things like kam-na and throwing techniques from Taijiquan that YKS and others learned from FSC.
It is not "missing" if it wasn't meant to be there originally.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
zuti car
When will you people stop putting down other styles
Like you just did to the entire YM clan in a wall of text.
Quote:
and invetning this kind of stories . Lying will not make your style better , the saddest part is that you actually believe in your own lies .
I did not invent the story of Fung Siu-ching, his Taijiquan background, and what types of things he taught to YKS, YCW, and others to add to the WC they had already learned.
It's common knowledge among those who have bothered to look, but people think YMVT is "incomplete" because he didn't learn and incorporate these foreign elements that are fundamentally conflicting with the VT fighting method.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
zuti car
When will you people stop putting down other styles and invetning this kind of stories
Also, it's not a put down to point out history and where certain things came from, why they are there and not here.
If someone can make it work, good for them, but YMVT functions best as intended and not tinkered with.