anyone know which linage of wing chun is this http://ph8tel.com/watch_video.php?v=79386c13962f87f
Printable View
anyone know which linage of wing chun is this http://ph8tel.com/watch_video.php?v=79386c13962f87f
Very interesting. I practice a rich Mainland Chinese lineage of Wing Chun, but it is very different from the what is on the video clip. I have been told that there are at least 7 different lineages of Wing Chun in Mainland China, so I guess we need to keep an open mind and hope that we are exposed to much more Wing Chun than the one dimensional view we get from most (perhaps not all) of the commercialized franchises.
IMHO, the art that is generally commercialized as Wing Chun here in the West, is a very limited view of this rich art.
I find the opening salutation interesting, as it's similar to guys I have seen in Foshan.
As for the lineage, at this time I don't know but will fill you in if I find out! :)
You mean this?
http://ph8tel.com/watch_video.php?v=ec0af81f5f865df
i've seen this before, and i think i want to say Yui Choi?
thats from memory, could be wrong!
Thought I'd seen that carpet before :)
Here is a youtube clip that compares Chum Kiu form: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tNm8HW8mL5c
Still no idea what the lineages are though.
I'm not sure, but we filmed Mak Yiu Mings students in China at the Ip Man Tong Opening and their Chum Kiu is the same. Cheung Bo Lineage I believe.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XZc0Lyw385U
Its not a line i have seen before....at least not a core form...
It looks to me to have other styles mixed in, family hung kuen, pak mei or maybe southern mantis.
Paul
www.moifa.co.uk
its chan yu ming lineage, via chan wah shun also called shunde wingchun because it comes from Shunde Guangzhou.
Can tell by their salutation and their movements, has hong kuen elements outside of the 3 sets of traditional wingchun.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fuiyo-hEDfU
Mak Yu Ming lineage has similar opening as Yuen Kay San, Sum Nung
Some info
The Lineage head, Chan Yu Min (陳汝棉) was the son of Chan Wah Shun (陳華順). He is the teacher of the renowned Grandmaster, Yip Man, who is the very teacher of Bruce Lee of international fame. Chan Yu Min taught to his 3 sons, Chan Kar Chai (陳家齊), Chan Kar Lim (陳家廉) and Chan Kar Sun(陳家燊). My Sifu's sifu, is the Kung Fu descendent of Chan Kar Lim and Chan Kar Sun .
I'm haven't read the thread, so forgive me if this has already been established....it's obviously not HK wing chun. I like it though, it's more kung fooey. I wish there was more wing chun like this in the states. Perhaps some of us should go and study abroad for a while to bring some of it back here?!