Lot of people like to talk about proof here but don't even bother to check all the sources
Type: Posts; User: theo
Lot of people like to talk about proof here but don't even bother to check all the sources
So these pictures prove what exactly?
Cho hong choi said in a written letter Hendrik could teach
If Hendrik showed up after yeung passed away how could he learn from him ?
zuti, you seem to ignore facts and talk without any real understanding on the subject. Wing Chun didn't exist in 1848? So you're saying Wong Wah Bo, Leung Jan, weren't doing Wing Chun? You have...
LFJ, in this case though, it's not someone just looking and saying it looks similar. GM Fu has gone through the writing from 1848 SLT and the Emei match up. Unless you're saying that he doesn't...
Both Emei writing and the SLT kuit have been passed down and separately preserved in the Emei and Cho family. From Jim's report, GM Fu confirms the YK SLT kuit contains Emei kuit, therefore 1848 YK...
i think on one hand, you've got the people making up theories and speculating while on the other, there are actual documents and multiple sources including the Emei lineage holder himself confirming...
GM Fu here is referring to the similarities between the 1848 version of SLT, and not the general SNT that is more common today.
Things have changed since then obviously as evolution occurred. ...
Did you read what Jim wrote? From Jim's comment:
to quote from WCI:
"Sifu Yik Kam’s Siu Lin Tau is a long set that has four parts and many sections in each part. The set is equal to the common three Wing Chun sets combined. In fact, the first...
VT Andy,
The announcement you quoted has been proved inaccurrate already in previous threads. Hendrik does have relationships with the Cho family and is a inheritor of his sifu's teachings by...
My view is that when doing the 2 person training, it requires the body kung of the solo training. I don't think anyone is saying you just have to do SLT and no drills, etc. The words you mentioned...
Andy, Hendrik has never claimed to be sole successor of Cho Gar, but he is one of many successors. His point is that he is qualified to teach and learned the complete system as taught by his sifu....
There are different ways of doing the set, and with that you get different result. And sometimes people add things into their sets for their own reasons.
I can say that what Hendrik shows is the...
great diagram, i was looking for that one to put on here, but u beat me to it!
I was in those discussion groups. To be honest, from what I saw, it was Hendrik sharing info and everyone else asking a few questions here and there for clarification.
all lineages have a bit different things, but none has it all. hendrik's not saying ykwc is superior but it has internal component to it and is what wck likely was pre-red boat via the one long set...
my understanding is hendrik's wck which has elements of both of those. it's that mix that gives wck its uniqueness as a separate art, just like u have taiji, etc. different than just studying emei,...
Daniel, if you look around on the net, Hendrik has been saying the same thing for over 10 years, that the wck mother arts are white crane and emei snake. the internal stuff is based on the emei, no...
Daniel, they look the same. Nothing new at all, it's impossible to be "identical" but it is the exact same motions trained in the same way.
I can't say since I wasn't there. I don't think either of them would "lie", my feeling is it could have been a misunderstanding somehow.
Daniel, I am neutral in this whole event, I have nothing to gain. I don't teach, I don't sell anything. But I can confirm the video exists, I have seen the footage myself. It shows Hendrik...
From the handwritten letters Hendrik showed, Hendrik is authorized to teach Cho family WCK as taught by his sifu Cho Hung Choy. Cho Hung Choy said this himself in the letter. Hendrik also has shown...
KPM, basically the announcement was saying Hendrik has nothing to do with Cho family and is not authorized to represent them, when there are letters showing his correspondence with Ku sifu and...
This announcement is showing up everywhere. Hendrik has responded to this on the Facebook group "wing Chun Forum" if anyone interested. There are photos of old letters between him and Cho family...
Keith, my understanding is they worked together to compare the kuits and found that they expressed similar content, even though both lineages are not related and separated for many years as SC...