Riiiight.... so a guy who posted so much, telling so many they had WCK all mixed up, just stopped caring and didn't want to explain why he was 'deliberately' letting someone hit him and throw him...
Type: Posts; User: BPWT..
Riiiight.... so a guy who posted so much, telling so many they had WCK all mixed up, just stopped caring and didn't want to explain why he was 'deliberately' letting someone hit him and throw him...
Agreed. I find it hard to believe that anyone would claim this Wing Chun forum was 'over' moderated :D
All of the points are correct. Some raised here, others raised on the German boards from people connected to those who train directly with PB, and none of it was disputed by PB or by Kevin, as far as...
To be sure, there is some biased thinking going on here. :eek: And more than a little revisionism, from some. There was a huge thread about this video clip at the time, and it was clear to pretty...
I think LFJ is based in Shanghai.
Just poking my head in, having a quick look around. Seems like everyone is on holiday. :D
In the article it says the two met in 2009, so maybe it was filmed then (?).
Well, I focused on Sam Kwok because he's the big name - I don't know anything about the other guy. But the unknown chap (unknown to me), looked better. And also showed far more control when striking....
I don't really understand this type of Poon Sau. Different from what I train.
Sam Kwok had very poor elbow positioning, IMO, and hence the other guy was routinely able to extend his arm and hit....
There's nothing wrong with having a good discussion and that then turning into a bit of an argument :) But the name-calling is something else. Not because its hurtful (sticks and stones, and all...
This is not really true, you know. I told you how I saw things... you and Graham said I was wrong. I explained why I think the way I do, and then explained why I don't agree with your take on things....
Sure we were. We have to listen to you doing your best to insult us. Which is a remedial way for a 40-year-old to act, but that's life I guess. There's no need to worry, however, Graham; Sanjuro...
And in post #486 and onwards I responded, explaining what I don't understand about what he'd said. That's the nature of a discussion. To ask more and to give feedback.... Rather than to listen and...
Only two from me:
1. Clean up and/or delete multiple threads about the same topic (e.g. Hendrik posting about 7 bows, etc, in hundreds of different threads :))
2. Ban people who persistently...
I think you're just repeating what PB told you, you haven't explained it by answering the questions I asked.
Answering means giving more than just:
"you are wrong."
"It doesn't."
"Little...
And you guys have had the nerve to tell me that Leung Ting makes up stuff. :confused::confused: Did these WSL seminar students get their money back?
Pure gold! :D Okay, I will ignore footage...
:D And what is a punch, for you Graham? A method of doing something to someone who isn't there? :D
Doesn't your SNT and CK work already focus on the execution, positioning and structure of your...
Okay, but would that contradict WSL's seminar footage? Simple question to answer, LFJ.
Would they also tell me to ignore the footage of WSL giving a seminar on the dummy?
Edit: Did you ever meet WSL? When you did, did he tell you to ignore his seminar footage?
It is strange logic from LFJ and Graham, IMO. To apply WCK motions and methods when training with the dummy and to think that the dummy's limbs are positioned in a way that doesn't correspond to the...
Eh? You mean it is a tool to train overreaching. :D:D
He talked about his own elbow positing as the reason for the height of the arms. I asked him why he needs that elbow positioning in...
You're free to leave the conversation, but I've noticed you often do this when someone doesn't agree with you and asks further questions. You've given some answers (though I think they need more...
You can train to not overreach, in this sense, without a dummy. Why do you use a tool that requires contact?
Graham hasn't really explained at all. Graham referenced WSL using a dummy that...
If you can see this, I just don't understand how you can't see what I am meaning.
The dummy was too high for WSL. This meant he couldn't use correct elbow positioning so had to use another part of...
Correct elbow positioning in relation to what? You are not fighting the air! So what is your reference point?
This makes no sense at all to me, Graham. Your optimal positioning has to be in...