Right. So, neither of us do this day in and day out, getting exposed to so many variables that we could possibly say anything authoritative. You can't really speak to what might have happenned and neither can I.
All we can do is speculate.
And that's my point about the straw man. My experiences don't invalidate or validate yours, and vice versa. It's not very useful to speak in terms of well, have YOU fought in 'x'? Goes nowhere in this type of conversation.
FWIW that guy sounds like a ****. Good job