Is Wing Chun Internal?

[YiQuanOne]

Not as hard as it would be for this supposed someone to convince me he isn't a total airhead.

.

Your the one with the questions, I could care less if you are convinced, your loss not mine.


Go back to your flat earth.

[anerlich]

Your the one with the questions

No, you're the one claiming to have answers to questions no one is asking.

I could care less if you are convinced

You argue a hell of a lot for someone who doesn't care. But not convincingly.

I thought you were going to take your bat and ball and go home a while back. Don't let me stop you.

[YiQuanOne]

No, you're the one claiming to have answers to questions no one is asking.



You argue a hell of a lot for someone who doesn't care. But not convincingly.

I thought you were going to take your bat and ball and go home a while back. Don't let me stop you.

This is an internal thread, go back to your external threads and stop trolling where you have no experence, it shows.

I'm sure there are people that are not as negative as you when it comes to learning something new.

I am not saying things that are not well known, you should do some research on your own.

[GlennR]

This is an internal thread, go back to your external threads and stop trolling where you have no experence, it shows.

I'm sure there are people that are not as negative as you when it comes to learning something new.

I am not saying things that are not well known, you should do some research on your own.

The thread is "is Wing Chun Internal?". Its a question.
That would invite people who both support or oppose that idea.

To say that anyone who opposes the idea, has no idea or experience regarding internal studies, is ignorant at the very least

So you cant read where people are located and cant comprehend the topic of the thread.

Do you need some reading and comprehension lessons?

[YiQuanOne]

The thread is "is Wing Chun Internal?". Its a question.
That would invite people who both support or oppose that idea.

To say that anyone who opposes the idea, has no idea or experience regarding internal studies, is ignorant at the very least

So you cant read where people are located and cant comprehend the topic of the thread.

Do you need some reading and comprehension lessons?

You are one of those guys that thinks "internal" does not exist.

The question asks if WC is internal , not whether "internal exists ?".

[GlennR]

You are one of those guys that thinks "internal" does not exist.

The question asks if WC is internal , not whether "internal exists ?".

Well if internal doesnt exist how can it be in WC?????????????????????!!!!!!!!!!

Leading to, no its not internal!!!!!

So your way of thinking is that i must believe internal exists for it NOT to be in WC??

Are you on crack?

[YiQuanOne]

Well if internal doesnt exist how can it be in WC?????????????????????!!!!!!!!!!

Leading to, no its not internal!!!!!

So your way of thinking is that i must believe internal exists for it NOT to be in WC??

Are you on crack?

No, but sounds like you are.

Yes, WC is "internal" but most people do the "external" version like youuuuuuuu!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Because they don't know what "internal" isssssss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[GlennR]

No, but sounds like you are.

Yes, WC is "internal" but most people do the "external" version like youuuuuuuu!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Because they don't know what "internal" isssssss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I know what it isnt...... an effective quanitfiable means of combat, WC in this case.

Now go have another puff

[wolf3001]

I think Wing Chun is a combination.

[anerlich]

I'm sure there are people that are not as negative as you when it comes to learning something new.

Hmmm.

Bac Fu Do KF starting 1977.

Meditation and other occult stuff with a theosophical group c. 79-81.

taiji/xingyi/bagua 1981-1987. Accupressure course and diploma c. 1985.

Wing Chun 1989-

Brazilian Jiu Jitsu 1999-

MMA 2006-2009

I daresay I'm way more open than you and your ilk to learning new stuff.

BTW, the crap you're going on about isn't new to me AT ALL. I meet internal "experts" all the time who can't explain five element theory, the eight trigrams or basic TCM concepts. I'm betting I know much more about it than you.

This is an internal thread, go back to your external threads and stop trolling where you have no experence, it shows.

This is getting annoying. It's

EXPERIENCE

with an I, OK?

[Hardwork108]

Hmmm.

Bac Fu Do KF starting 1977.

Meditation and other occult stuff with a theosophical group c. 79-81.

taiji/xingyi/bagua 1981-1987. Accupressure course and diploma c. 1985.

Wing Chun 1989-

Brazilian Jiu Jitsu 1999-

MMA 2006-2009

I daresay I'm way more open than you and your ilk to learning new stuff.

BTW, the crap you're going on about isn't new to me AT ALL. I meet internal "experts" all the time who can't explain five element theory, the eight trigrams or basic TCM concepts. I'm betting I know much more about it than you.



This is getting annoying. It's

EXPERIENCE

with an I, OK?

Studying all of the above in a Mcdojo does not count. Nor does it count when you are studying it with people who are not willing to share the knowledge with you, for obvious reasons, I might add.

[Hardwork108]

I think Wing Chun is a combination.

I would go further and say that all major kung fu styles are a combintation of Internal and External (Yin/Yang). The proportions will differ according to a given style, but they are there and they COMPLIMENT each other as far as the art and its EFFECTIVENESS are concerned.

[Hardwork108]

I know what it isnt...... an effective quanitfiable means of combat, WC in this case.

Now go have another puff

Study the Internals first, before you make any more clueless comments.

[Hardwork108]

Well if internal doesnt exist how can it be in WC?????????????????????!!!!!!!!!!

Leading to, no its not internal!!!!!

So your way of thinking is that i must believe internal exists for it NOT to be in WC??

Are you on crack?

What YiQuanOne is actually saying is that you are trolling this thread cluelessly, without a point of reference.

[GlennR]

What YiQuanOne is actually saying is that you are trolling this thread cluelessly, without a point of reference.

God knows what he's saying.
Though you seem to think like him so i'll put you in the fantasy fu boys club with him.