Is Shaolin-Do for real?

[hskwarrior]

3. Yuen Hai spent time in Indonesia

what part didn't you get? Yuen Hai NEVER went to indonesia. He was the right hand man for Cheung Hung Sing and stayed at his side until his teachers death.

so you've been proven wrong on #3. So, the fact that Yuen Hai never went to indonesia can no longer be interesting to you cause he was never there.

You're trusting information that comes from a student of Doc Fai Wong, who, once claimed in his book that the Green Grass Monk was just a myth then retracted his comment and claimed he learned the true identity of the Green Grass Monk and that it was the Monk Choy Fook, Chan Heung's third teacher. But book will prove that ridiculousness wrong as i know monk choy fook is not the green grass monk. so if you want to believe doc fai wong's incorrect account of his own grand master go right ahead. Go on and play with the idea that yuen hai was in indonesia even though it is a lie. my comments here mark the fact that i am saying its a lie.

[tattooedmonk]

1. Yuen Hai taught Lau Bun
2. Yuen Hai's wife taught Lau Bun 5 Animals
3. Yuen Hai spent time in Indonesia

Do you see where this is going?

There is obviously a difference of opinion on the facts. Doc Fai Wong is a reputable source for most things. He is an author, producer of kung fu videos, teaches world wide and has thousands of students.... You be the judge. I do wonder if Yuen Hai went to Indonesia, it's possible. And highly probable.

[tattooedmonk]

I've believed Sin The' learned the 5 animal form from doc Fai wong's book. Primarily based on the release date of the book and when Sin The' taught the form. Both around 1990.
But this little tidbit does open the door to speculation.

It's possible he got it from a book. Even that book. But there are certain questions that should and haven't been answered.....

[hskwarrior]

There is obviously a difference of opinion on the facts. Doc Fai Wong is a reputable source for most things. He is an author, producer of kung fu videos, teaches world wide and has thousands of students.... You be the judge. I do wonder if Yuen Hai went to Indonesia, it's possible. And highly probable.

LMAO. keep wondering wonder boy. it's just as probable as the monkey circus attraction shaolin monk.

[hskwarrior]

It's possible he got it from a book. Even that book. But there are certain questions that should and haven't been answered.....

when you become relevant to the Choy Lee Fut system you'd get answers. but you're not. so you won't. Plus I'm going to trust DFW's SENIOR classmate (My Grand Master) before i believe him.

the only truth is SIN THE learned our form from the book. plain and simple. Dragon grabs the rainbow and all. hahaha.

[bodhi warrior]

It's possible he got it from a book. Even that book. But there are certain questions that should and haven't been answered.....

I always try to keep an open mind. And would love to be wrong on this. What questions were you thinking?

[bawang]

we are harsh on shaolin do people.

kung fu is so infignificant in america, nobody had ever cared or will care if they claim to be shaolin. and they themselves dont understand the reason why its wrong. shaolin is just a far away fairy tale. what matters to them is that they lost weight and made friends.

shaolin do is the purest heart of american kung fu, stripped away of all formalities and political correctness. its the ultimate fantasy power trip. kung fu people are ashamed of shaolin do because it reminds them of themselves. the only difference is their form and lineage is "authentic".

[hskwarrior]

and they themselves dont understand the reason why its wrong

that's what i don't get. regardless of how many people telling them how wrong it is, it completely misses them. maybe its because they see it as a cash cow and don't really care.
but it's a **** shame they choose to remain ignorant of the truth set before them.

[tattooedmonk]

I always try to keep an open mind. And would love to be wrong on this. What questions were you thinking?

I would like to know either way, it won't change the fact that I know the form , can teach the form and perform the form without any problems. It has many martial, medicinal and meditative benefits. No one is going to change that.

[tattooedmonk]

Do you study Chinese martial arts ( kung fu) from Indonesia; Kuntao or Silat?!? Do you know anything about the Malay culture and how they live?!?

Have you done any research or read any books on the subject?! Yes or no questions that should be easy to answer without any ego or drama.

Please answer honestly and appropriately. I will not respond to any other nonsense.

[bawang]

that's what i don't get. regardless of how many people telling them how wrong it is, it completely misses them. maybe its because they see it as a cash cow and don't really care.
but it's a **** shame they choose to remain ignorant of the truth set before them.

shaolin do reminds me of black hebrew israelites. ever see them at chinatown?

[hskwarrior]

I would like to know either way, it won't change the fact that I know the form , can teach the form and perform the form without any problems. It has many martial, medicinal and meditative benefits. No one is going to change that.

i would stake my life on the fact that you truly do not demonstrate the form as it is supposed to be done. of this i'm extremely confident. stolen form or not. you learned DOC FAI WONG's BOOK VERSION of the true form along with SIN THE's attempts to disguise it.. YOU don't know the form!

[hskwarrior]

shaolin do reminds me of black hebrew israelites. ever see them at chinatown?

not in CT but i see the video's of them in NY. yeah i agree, shaolin do falls in like with black isrealites.

[bawang]

not in CT but i see the video's of them in NY. yeah i agree, shaolin do falls in like with black isrealites.

like all cults, its about what they feel. shaolin do elicits a feeling they as kentucky hillbillies never experienced.

[hskwarrior]

Lmao.]....................