Is Shaolin-Do for real?

[Shaolin Wookie]

Dude, has anyone told you that you are full of crap?

Yes, but since it came from a piece of poo, I just smiled and laughed in spite of him.

[Baqualin]

from whom? did ie travel to korea?

GMIe's travels were before he settled in Indonesia.....pre 50's......plus their calling their whole system Pakua plus it states he was the sole succesor of the system...ck your PM

[Mas Judt]

Hey BQ,
Here are some clips of CMA in Malaysia -

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z9Wspd7GOb8

Except for the comment that CMA does not exist in China anymore (had me rolling on the floor - that IS very funny), it's a pretty neat example of CMA in the Nusantra.

As far as that guy - who knows - does he really claim it is the SAME Master Ie?

I've seen other tools claim ownership of entire 'mun', Gene Chocoine for example, or Sin The' on his websites (only Shaolin Grandmaster). It is a silly concept, and seems dependent upon people not knowing better and a lack of information.

I do find it odd that he claims Master Ie - I mean why bother unless he DID learn from him, as Master Ie is not really that well known outside of SD. Sin the' is also very clear that Ie did not teach non-Chinese. While it is not unheard of for a teacher to issue a certificate for cash and no training, especially in times of need, it all does kinda make you wonder.

Is there still an existing branch of Ie's school in Bandung? What do they call themselves?

[Citong Shifu]

Hey BQ,
Here are some clips of CMA in Malaysia -

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z9Wspd7GOb8

Except for the comment that CMA does not exist in China anymore (had me rolling on the floor - that IS very funny), it's a pretty neat example of CMA in the Nusantra.

As far as that guy - who knows - does he really claim it is the SAME Master Ie?

I've seen other tools claim ownership of entire 'mun', Gene Chocoine for example, or Sin The' on his websites (only Shaolin Grandmaster). It is a silly concept, and seems dependent upon people not knowing better and a lack of information.

I do find it odd that he claims Master Ie - I mean why bother unless he DID learn from him, as Master Ie is not really that well known outside of SD. Sin the' is also very clear that Ie did not teach non-Chinese. While it is not unheard of for a teacher to issue a certificate for cash and no training, especially in times of need, it all does kinda make you wonder.

Is there still an existing branch of Ie's school in Bandung? What do they call themselves?

Of course there is or are many branch schools of Master Ie in Bandung or surrounding area's. After all, he taught more than just one desciple. From my understanding he had a fairly large school while in Indonesia. I'm not sure what they call themselves, but JP and some of the other guys were commenting on this subject a little while back... Can you guys (SD) spread some light on this please. I would like to look into the arts/styles taught in Bandung as well..

Thanks.
CS

[brucereiter]

Of course there is or are many branch schools of Master Ie in Bandung or surrounding area's. After all, he taught more than just one desciple. From my understanding he had a fairly large school while in Indonesia. I'm not sure what they call themselves, but JP and some of the other guys were commenting on this subject a little while back... Can you guys (SD) spread some light on this please. I would like to look into the arts/styles taught in Bandung as well..

Thanks.
CS

i have very little information about this topic but here are a few things i was told by my teacher about one of ie chang mings students.
"chi tung" was a student of grand master ie chang ming in bandung. i do not know the correct spelling of his name or how to contact him but my teacher met chi tung on their 1992 trip to bandung and did push hands etc with him and his senior student. i was told their tai chi chuan was very good.

another name i have been told about is "su tay" ... i have no idea how to spell his name . i understand that he is the person who gave gmt the case with all of the old notes from ie chang ming in 1992.

best,

bruce

[BlueTravesty]

Hey BQ,
Here are some clips of CMA in Malaysia -

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z9Wspd7GOb8

Except for the comment that CMA does not exist in China anymore (had me rolling on the floor - that IS very funny), it's a pretty neat example of CMA in the Nusantra.

Didn't you get the memo? All that stuff is Modern Wushu It's the Time-Traveling Modern Wushu Conspiracy. Not only did they manage to exterminate every last TCMA practitioner in one of the most populous countries on earth (statistics, schmatistics) the PRC went back in time 100 years and changed martial arts forms to look all "different"

Also the earth is flat and the sky is green.

[Judge Pen]

i have very little information about this topic but here are a few things i was told by my teacher about one of ie chang mings students.
"chi tung" was a student of grand master ie chang ming in bandung. i do not know the correct spelling of his name or how to contact him but my teacher met chi tung on their 1992 trip to bandung and did push hands etc with him and his senior student. i was told their tai chi chuan was very good.

another name i have been told about is "su tay" ... i have no idea how to spell his name . i understand that he is the person who gave gmt the case with all of the old notes from ie chang ming in 1992.

best,

bruce

"Su tay", or as I've heard it pronounced "Su Fei", was a college of Master Ie but not part of the same school. He was the one that gave him the cases of Ie's notes from what I've been told.

[kungfujunky]

i believe su fei also requested hsing yi tutelage from gmt at the same time he gave the notes

[kungfujunky]

i just double checked my notes and gmt told us all at a festival that story and he did in fact teach su fei hsing I.

[bodhi warrior]

The guys in that video have a "flavor" that's very similar to the way I was taught. I'll take that over modern shaolin any day.

[Shaolin-Do]

SHaolin Do is t3h real...
SO real it resurrects itself from the grave... as in my case.

Fear and be baffled by my awe inspiring powers....

Jesus...
I forgot the password to this account for years... literally...
And beautifully enough, I just remembered it.


... And remember, Support local hip hop!
f*ckers.

[BM2]

[QUOTE=Shaolin-Do;825037]

I forgot the password to this account for years... literally...
And beautifully enough, I just remembered it.

QUOTE]


Ahhh...We are soo lucky

[BM2]

I found out alittle about the pa kua guy who studied with Ie chang ming. Back in the 60's he studied aikido and karate. He went to a tournament or something in Korea, and someone told him of master ie. He said that no matter what you did you couldn't touch him. The pa kua guy met master ie and ask him to teach him. Master ie refused but eventually gave in when offered alot of money. According to my source, pa kua is all he learned from master ie. This is the info I was given.

Could you ask when he studied? I do know that Master Sin paid quite a bit more than the other students because his parents could afford it. That is paraphrased from what he had said. I usually refrain from quoting other people.

[kwaichang]

Go on You Tube and key in best fighter of the world and tell me what those guys are wearing ??? KC

[Mas Judt]

let me guess... japanese underwear?

who cares?

the gi thing doesn't really matter. it is the least of the questions about sd.