Unlock IS-Dfr. Merge all S-D threads together so it clears 1000 posts!
Unlock IS-Dfr. Let all the S-D threads stand independently.
Keep IS-Dfr locked down. All IS-Dfr posters deserved to be punished.
Delete them all. Let Yama sort them out.
[QUOTE=Judge Pen;936775]You honestly believe that early okinawan martial arts had no words for the techniques? They didn't call a punch a punch in their native dilect? Come on, your dense but no-one is that dense.
So they called a punch a pucnh and a kick a kick in their native dialect. Then once it was given the Japanese treatment, they started using japanese terms because that made sense to the japanese that were learning the okinawan art. Fine, but a punch is still a punch, you've just changed the language that your using. That's a far cry from saying that there was no terminology.
And you, as a student of goju ryu, use american terms and chinese terms to describe an art that used to use okinawan and japaese words. Because that makes sense to you at this time. Ok, whatever works for you.
I'm sorry, if you don't see the parallels then you must have gotten hit to hard in the head before.
oh dear lord you gusy are as thick as a brick lol
its like trying to tell a dog not to crap o n the carpet and they give you that dumb look lol
no where did i say the okinawans didnt have a language they were just so casula bout there method to teaching they didnt have names for anything you just shut your hole and practiced wha the master physically demonstrated they didnt even have dojos to train at at the start
look at this qote fro dr christian harafouche
"karate originally was a purely unorganized unphilosphical form of self defense"
Go Ju you are so full of it. 1st there wasnt Karate in Japan prior to 1921 they had a striking art called Uchi waza or striking technique. It was a part of sumotori the ancient wrestling art known as Sumo now. Also the Japanese did not have Kata until Jigoro Kano introduce the art of Judo until then it was based on the samurai arts used in war fare. You really are a joke. Any more Karate talk Boy? KC
A Fool is Born every Day !
GoJu RYU has been around for 2000 years and is from China from what I read . Since the early 1800s they have been documenting their art. So that is almost two hundred years If you lernedit recently then you would know the names of forms , proper terminolgy etc.
You my friend have no idea what you are talking about. but I am still bored and waiting for the walls to dry in my bathroom!!
are we speaking two diferrent languages here lol where did i say i dont know them i know all the names of the forms and moves in japanese like the majority of goju guys do
we can go around about when it was actually created but i keep it like this goju as a art was created when choju miyagi founded it and began teaching it to the publi
PARTS of it came from kung fu though not all of it so you cant really say it is from china
Quite simply I was a student of theirs 3 are Shotokan trained by Funakoshi 1 is Aikido and one Iaido and Kendo KC
A Fool is Born every Day !
Its origins is in Fujien White Crane. Read the book Bubishi Then you can say you know something. KC
A Fool is Born every Day !