Originally Posted by
neilhytholt
Well, please don't take my comments the wrong way. I'm not putting down Tai chi or anything. It's just that I'm a bit frustrated with the teachers out there, and the lack of applications. I think that part of this is due to their wanting to continue to make money, without providing students with any real fighting skills.
In my experience, chinese culture has a lot of face saving things.
Let me gives you some examples.
'Steal'. The student 'stole' that. Means they either learned it from another person, learned it by watching, or learned it and now are teaching without permission.
Many masters will say their students 'stole' things from them, which means that the student is teaching and the instructor isn't getting the $$$ from the teaching.
'Stupid'. Somebody is 'stupid'. Means not necessarily that they're stupid, but they are from a different lineage, do something differently from the teacher, etc.
'I know, but I don't tell you, because I want you to figure it out.' This means that they probably don't know, or they want to string you along for years and years, making $$$ off of you in the process.
'It's too deadly for the ring'. Means they don't have the skills to properly apply it in the ring, or don't have the control not to hurt their opponent, or they just don't want to fight at all for fear of getting hurt.
Usually, 'it's too deadly for the ring', means they don't have the skills to apply it and never actually fought with anybody. A lot of people have a false sense of confidence from this.
'It's too hard and takes years to master'. Sun Lu Dong studied bagua for what, 3 years? Xingyi for how long? Taiji for how long? So when somebody tells you it takes years and years, sure, it might take years, but likely they don't have the goods, or can't teach it.
So instead you get people studying taiji for 25 years who have 0 fighting skills, only basic push-hands skills, never actually practiced against a resisting opponent in a sparring situation or a ring or anything, who then go on to teach.
So I don't know about your tai chi at all, just that the tricks of throwing people around and stuff aren't a big deal. sure, you can snap a guy's wrist or something maybe, but can you control him without snapping? Aikido people can control without snapping (well some of them can).