i beg to differ with you joseph.
You act like I say Chan Heung's personal history is wrong. I've never done that. I admit that the chan family has a lot of holes in their story. So does the Hung Sing Kwoon.
I've never told someone not to join the chan family of CLF. I've never spoken ill of Chan Family CLF.
When i asked the questions about Jeong Yim, i wanted to demonstrate that if anyone wants to know about Fut San Hung SIng Kwoon, they should 1) either go to fut san and do some research, 2) research as much material on this branch as you can.
See, I believe in the Fut San Hung Sing Kwoon is because of the info that comes out of it such as it's involvement in the Hung Mun and the Revolution is easily traceable.
Until now most everybody had only heard the Chan Family version of CLF. The Hung Sing branch has always passed down our history orally. No one new that the Fut San HSK was still active undgerground until the late 1990's. They re-emerged and since then everyone is wanting to know the history according to Jeong Hung Sing, which is slightly different to that of Chan Heung.
anyways, Chan Heung's account of Jeong Yim seems to be really different to that of his own direct branches account. Chan Ngau Sing's account of his sifu differs from that of Chan Heung. Yuen Hai's account to Lau Bun differs from Chan Family CLF about Jeong Yim.
Speaking of Yuen Hai, I believe in the Fut San Hung SIng Kwoon so much that if we wanted to.......we ....Professor Lau Bun's branch.......could take advantage of the Chan Family account of Yuen Hai being Loong Gee Choi's first student. Since Loong Gee Choy is Chan Heung's First student, that places Yuen Hai's lineage amongst the highest in Choy Lee Fut, even higher than Koon Pak, and such.
however, we believe in the fut san lineage of Hung SIng Choy Lee Fut.