Review of Ba Gua Zhang books and articles

[SPJ]

Which book or article you read about Ba Gua Zhang?

Like it or dislike it?

why?

comments?

[SPJ]

A lot of people like Jiang Rong Qiao book " Ba Gua Zhang".

I like the book written by Chen Quan Lian about Liang style.

Liang Zhen Pu-> Li Zi Ming->

---

there are discussions about the oral transmission from Dong.

[SPJ]

I also like Liu Jing Ru's book on Cheng Ting Hua style of Ba Gua.

There are some good discussions of the general theory.

however, the pictures are too poor to see clearly. They are too grayish or too dark, no good contrast. if only it is in color, I wish--

luckily, I have his vcd's from the 90'.

So I was reading the text and watching vcd's to "grasp" what he meant.

Applications are mentioned but not discussed in detail or at higher level or integrating levels etc.

if only applications are discussed more in the book, I wish--

[jack]

Anyone try reading taiwan ba gua palms books before?

[SPJ]

http://www.chinafrominside.com/ma/bagua/liujingru.html

A link to an intro of Liu.

[SPJ]

http://users2.ev1.net/~stma/BaguaLibrary.html

A link to some books.