Originally Posted by
TenTigers
I wil lbriefly address BPB's statement, only to clarify things so we can get on with a discussion. I will take for granted that you are simply not trolling, or starting that tired argument about CMA not training realistically-each school is different so don't judge CMA by a few (or alot) of what you have seen.
There are CMA schools that are hands on, stress conditioning,reaction drills, hard contact,ground fighting, and constant pressure testing, fighting with their Gung-Fu,with forms and demos taking less of a priority.
By the way, if you do your research, this is not a new delema, but siomething that has been going on for HUNDREDS of years.
Secondly, we are usingthe term "Wu-SHu" to mean the contemporary Martial Performance art created in PRC. Yeas, we all know that wu-shu actually means milatary/martial art, guo-shu means National Art, but China has decised that Wu-Shu is the official name of this art. They can change the meansings of words just as easily as they can change forms in MA/ Remember they have decided that Ch'uan is spelled quan,ch'i is spelled qi, shing is spelled xing, so why are we not surprised?
Wu-Shu is China's National Treasure, National SPort and National Pastime. Since all revolutions against the Chinese Govt were started by Martial Artists, they removed the combat applications, and to instill national pride, they remodled the forms to be aesthetically pleasing with acrobatics and posture taken from Opera and poses taken from the propaganda posters. (remove Mao Jacket, farm tools and red book, insert silks,staff and broadsword-presto-chango-Wu-Shu)
As far as the wushu-ization of TCMA is concerned, it is even worse than that-since the 79's people have "jazzed up" their forms for demos, competitions, to the point that they are laughable. Famous Sifus and Masters have schools that are a mere shadow of their former glory, as the inmates are now running the asylums, and they compromise their art for the sake of commercialization. Their forms start to change to keep up with the times-set forth by open Karate tournaments, television, whatever, and they are either to tired to resist, or they fear they will lose their students to the guy down the block.
But there are some of us, few, but some, who stick to our guns. we are "Dinosaurs" but these Dianosaurs also train their students so the art is NOT watered down, and gains strength each generation. We have open minds enough to do whatever it takes to improve our art and our students. Not by making it a chop-suey art, but by training attributes, skills,technique.