Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 16

Thread: Fact or Fiction? Is it achievable thru Tai Chi training?

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Sydney Australia
    Posts
    943

    Fact or Fiction? Is it achievable thru Tai Chi training?

    I copied this from wikepeadia:

    Munenori in Fiction and Legend

    Like his father, and his son Jubei, Munenori has achieved a degree of legendary status. A number of exaggerated tales and abilities have been attributed to him.

    One of the most often repeated is the tale of his amazing sense of danger approaching. He was meditating in his garden facing away from the door when his assistant brought him his sword silently and without any declarations. His assistant, being a young and imaginative sort of person, thought to himself how it would be interesting to see if he could attack Munenori from this position. Before he could act on the fantasy, Munenori leapt to his feet and turned around, stunned to discover only his assistant was behind him. He was sure there was some impending danger.

    Later on he was still troubled by the event. How could he have mistaken his assistant for impending danger? Was he losing his edge? He spoke of the incident to one of his trusted advisors while his assistant was in the room, and, being a virtuous youth, his assistant admitted that he had "thought" about attacking him earlier, but made no physical movements in accordance with the attack. Therefore, Munenori concluded that he was not in fact losing his edge but had actually achieved a new level of swordsmanship, one where a man can anticipate impending danger even when people are thinking about it.


    Do you think it can be systematically developed thru internal training?

    Cheers,
    John
    Dr. J Fung
    www.kulowingchun.com

    "打得好就詠春,打得唔好就dum春"

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Dec 2002
    Location
    Biosphere
    Posts
    245
    I think such sensitivity can be developed, perhaps by one in a million people, if even that. IME being able to discern the internal states of other human beings is a natural thing, not "psychic" per se, but a more fundamental wiring, like the species-specific wiring that allows a school of fish or a flight of birds to all change direction simultaneously.
    Last edited by scholar; 07-24-2006 at 11:13 PM.

  3. #3
    You've got mail.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Jan 2002
    Location
    Orlando, Florida
    Posts
    1,994
    Greetings..

    It is ALL achievable.. according to the degree you actually belive it is.. but, it's one thing to SAY you believe it, quite another to actually believe..

    When you understand the Quantum Field, the Zero Point Field, and energetic coherence.. you see how achievable anything is.. Yet, we are infants on this journey, only a nano-percentage of the population has the faith to reap the rewards..

    Be well..
    TaiChiBob.. "the teacher that is not also a student is neither"

  5. #5
    I think this is an ability that's very hard to train for in modern days. Except maybe for those that are on active law enforcement/military duties.

    We DO see this type of behavior/ability in the animal kingdom though. Have you ever try to sneak up on a cat or dog or any bird for that matter?

  6. #6
    One thing not mentioned in the story is that the style of swordsmanship practiced by the Yagyu, “Shinkage-ryu”, was essentially an internal form of swordsmanship. By saying this I mean that it is primarily mental and secondarily physical. The son of Munenori, Mitsuyoshi wrote this about the style:

    ”The sword of the Shinkage School is not a Yang blade, but a Yin (kage) blade; it does not employ any posture, its posture being posturelessness. The position of the Shinkage School is to do things in response to the opponent’s moves. It is a school that aims not to slash, not to take, not to win, not to lose.”

    Some of the noteworthy sayings of Muneyoshi, Munenori's father include:

    In swordsmanship, always train and discipline yourself,
    But don’t show it-hide it, be modest about it.

    If your mind reaches the ultimate in swordsmanship,
    the sword and other implements will have no place.


    The Yagyu were noteworthy for besting swordsmen in duels using “muto” that is “no sword” technique. At times they would essentially fight without a sword and disarm their opponent to defeat them.

    Munenori was quite good friends with a noted Zen master named Takuan Soho. Takuan was also a good friend of Miyamoto Musashi. There are elements of Zen in the training of Shinkage-ryu.

    The story mentioned above is an illustration of intuition, that is all. It is not an unusual story if one is familiar with stories of Zen masters. It is rather common amongst Zen masters to acquire such abilities. This intuitive ability is not dependent upon physical training of any kind; it is a condition of mind. It is an ability that occurs naturally, of itself (tzu-jan), when one achieves insight into the essence of mind, the state of “no-mind”, which is the purpose of Zen.

    Both Munenori and Musashi applied Zen principles to their swordsmanship and integrated Zen methods of training the mind with the fundamentals of swordsmanship. That is, in an attempt to delve into the depths of swordsmanship they discovered that all physical forms are nothing but expressions of the mind. To attain the highest level of form one must understand the essence of mind. To both men mental training became the essence of swordsmanship. Eventually, to each, swordsmanship merely represented the “useful expedient” utilized to attain realization. As a consequence, they were both essentially undefeatable in swordsmanship!

    “To master oneself, is to be master of all things!”
    Last edited by Scott R. Brown; 07-25-2006 at 08:52 AM.

  7. #7
    Quote Originally Posted by scholar
    I think such sensitivity can be developed, perhaps by one in a million people, if even that. IME being able to discern the internal states of other human beings is a natural thing, not "psychic" per se, but a more fundamental wiring, like the species-specific wiring that allows a school of fish or a flight of birds to all change direction simultaneously.
    I disagree. It can be developed by anyone who puts in the time.

    I can sense people a block or two away who are focusing on me on occasion. I am not a kung fu expert. Just some guy who has been practicing for years.

    The other day some guy at the store was homing in on me. I turned around and faced him about 5 seconds before he actually got to where I was. I could feel something homing in on me.

    If you look into this kind of stuff, you will find that the people who develop these abilities are usually hermits. Or they live a hermit like life. They are so used to just their energy that when the energy of another human being enters their vicinity they can pick it up. They are used to absolutley nothing being their.

    So if you really want the ability, living a hermit like life won't hurt.

  8. #8
    Quote Originally Posted by JohnnyMnemonic
    I disagree. It can be developed by anyone who puts in the time.

    I can sense people a block or two away who are focusing on me on occasion. I am not a kung fu expert. Just some guy who has been practicing for years.

    The other day some guy at the store was homing in on me. I turned around and faced him about 5 seconds before he actually got to where I was. I could feel something homing in on me.

    If you look into this kind of stuff, you will find that the people who develop these abilities are usually hermits. Or they live a hermit like life. They are so used to just their energy that when the energy of another human being enters their vicinity they can pick it up. They are used to absolutley nothing being their.

    So if you really want the ability, living a hermit like life won't hurt.
    I agree that is can be acquired by anyone who puts in the time and, as with all things, some people with have a greater aptitude than others. However, I disagree that it is necessary to live like a hermit. The Yagyu were active participants in the government of the Tokugawa. As a consequence they were bound by many official superfluous duties and meaningless, but required details and ceremony. One could argue they were blessed with an aptitude and this may be so, but it is not required to be a hermit.

    It does require a transcendence of, or regularly scheduled withdrawal from, the world system. This ability is a quality of mind and therefore the mind must have periods of reduced distraction in order to be conditioned or actually uncondition.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Detroit area
    Posts
    91
    Yep, I agree with all of the above. Notice he was meditating, which is most likely how he developed the sensitivity.

    I've just begun making a study of THE UNFETTERED MIND bu Takuan Soho. This is my first foray into sword fighting theory and Japanese Zen. Thick stuff.
    Give me immortality or give me death!

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Sydney Australia
    Posts
    943
    Quote Originally Posted by DarinHamel

    I've just begun making a study of THE UNFETTERED MIND bu Takuan Soho. This is my first foray into sword fighting theory and Japanese Zen.
    More than just sword fighting. Really good stuff. Enjoy!

    Cheers,
    John
    Dr. J Fung
    www.kulowingchun.com

    "打得好就詠春,打得唔好就dum春"

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Jan 1970
    Location
    UK
    Posts
    1,042

    hmmmm

    As mentioned a few posts ago, yes of course this can be developed by anybody who is willing to train the appropriate amount of time and effort required to acheive this.

    It is a real quality!
    People have this acheivement today.
    " Don't confuse yourself with someone who has something to say " - The Fall

    " I do not like your tone/ It has ephemeral whingeing aspects " - The Fall

    " There are twelve people in the world/ The rest are paste " - Mark E Smith

  12. #12
    cjurakpt Guest
    one day I had dinner at my sifu's home; afterwards, my older training sister and I were bringing the dishes to the sink, where we seperated them, putting the plates and utensils into a plastic basin to pre-soak before washing, and the larger pots, etc. into the sink; right when I started to put a sharp bread knife into the plastic basin, sifu, says, in a real calm, almost detached voice, "Dan Yang, don't put that knife in the basin - clean it and put it away."

    no big deal, except: he was sitting at the other end of the kitchen about 15' away, and I had my back to him, and from where he was sitting, there was no way he saw what I was doing in front of me; also, the basin was in the sink, so he couldn't have seen what I was sorting unles she'd been standing right behind me; and my training sister was behind me, obstructing his line of sight as well - from the look on her face when he said that, I knew that she knew there was no way he could have seen me either; also, he's near-sighted, so anything more than a few feet away is blurry; and it was noisy, since his wife and three daughters were also in the kitchen talking...

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Jan 1970
    Location
    Sydney, Australia
    Posts
    1,863
    I was sitting at a red light waiting for the light to turn green in my car, It turned green and i usually take off, when something inside me said dont go yet just sit there. I did that and the cars behind quickly reminded me to go which i didnt then a car went through a red light that would have taken me right out on my side of the car. It was freaky and i just new something was wrong!!!

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Jan 1970
    Location
    Anchorage, Alaska
    Posts
    1,317
    The quality your sifu expressed here is no different from someone who has years of experience in a kitchen and when cooking with them intuitively has sensitivity for things going on. They often have made mistakes if you'll cal lthem that, or seen similar things before, and their intuition kicks in and they make sure you don't do wrongly. It's simply intuition, both inherent and developed through experience.


    Quote Originally Posted by cjurakpt
    one day I had dinner at my sifu's home; afterwards, my older training sister and I were bringing the dishes to the sink, where we seperated them, putting the plates and utensils into a plastic basin to pre-soak before washing, and the larger pots, etc. into the sink; right when I started to put a sharp bread knife into the plastic basin, sifu, says, in a real calm, almost detached voice, "Dan Yang, don't put that knife in the basin - clean it and put it away."

    no big deal, except: he was sitting at the other end of the kitchen about 15' away, and I had my back to him, and from where he was sitting, there was no way he saw what I was doing in front of me; also, the basin was in the sink, so he couldn't have seen what I was sorting unles she'd been standing right behind me; and my training sister was behind me, obstructing his line of sight as well - from the look on her face when he said that, I knew that she knew there was no way he could have seen me either; also, he's near-sighted, so anything more than a few feet away is blurry; and it was noisy, since his wife and three daughters were also in the kitchen talking...

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Location
    The house of God
    Posts
    373
    I'm naturally empathic, but with how I grew up, I had to repress pretty much all of the ability and mostly forgot about it. I "unrepressed" it a few years ago, since I was able to handle it better. So, yeah, it can be confusing at times, if you aren't used to it and don't understand how to deal with it and protect yourself.

    But, if you want to develop it, look towards mysticism for additional teachings for your Tai Chi, but to start off, there's a really simple exercise to do.

    Just as you would direct chi through your body for any number of things, from chi kung to a basic flushing of your system, you need to put energy into the idea that you can do this skill, that you have this ability right now. Not that your ability is growing in it. That may seem like the easier path, but it screws you up in the end. You need to put energy into the end result, which is that you can pick up on emotions. Just as a college student psyches themselves up, while they're studying for a test, by saying 'I know this stuff, I can do this stuff', you need to do that, too, for this situation.

    You need to have such a strong first person visualization, just like is taught in most fighting systems when just visualizing a fight, either with movements for practice by yourself or without moving at all and it's more a meditation exercise.

    You image that you can mentally pick up on emotions, but that they won't control you. If you decide not to learn any shielding work, it's best to have a strong sense in the present that you can be aware of emotions, but that you don't take on those emotions, so you are subject to the whims of the emotions of others. That's a real problem. It'll just be info that pops into your head.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •