Banned Sport Gains Fans, and Seeks More in Albany
By PETER DUFFY
New York Times
Published: January 20, 2009
When Lou Neglia first opened his Brooklyn martial arts academy in 1974, students wanted to learn kung fu, inspired by the television show starring David Carradine. Then karate enjoyed a surge of interest after the release of the 1984 film “The Karate Kid.” Now nearly everyone who enters Mr. Neglia’s school in Gravesend wants to learn mixed martial arts, the wildly popular staple of cable and pay-per-view television.
“It’s the fastest-growing sport in the country,” said Mr. Neglia, a former world kickboxing champion, in a rapid-fire delivery that he interrupted to take a stream of business calls. “Boxing is dead.”
Mr. Neglia, 58, teaches the fighting style, which combines punching, grappling and kicking, and he is a regional promoter of the sport. In 2009, he will host five mixed martial arts events at the Tropicana in Atlantic City. Each will feature fighters from New York, where mixed martial arts competitions are banned.
It is a prohibition Mr. Neglia finds frustrating. “It doesn’t make any sense,” he said, adding that the sport “could be a major boost to the economy.” Mr. Neglia is among the many people involved in mixed martial arts who are seeking to overturn the ban.
The principal force behind the effort is the Ultimate Fighting Championship, the largest mixed martial arts association in the world.
The association, which is based in Las Vegas and is the major leagues of mixed martial arts, has hired a law firm, Brown, McMahon & Weinraub, to lobby Albany officials. It also hired a consulting firm, the Global Strategy Group, to handle media and political relations. Global Strategy advises Gov. David A. Paterson as well as many Democrats in the State Senate.
Fighters have also traveled to Albany to meet with legislators, and bloggers have organized petition drives and urged letter-writing campaigns.
Those hoping to legalize the sport face a difficult challenge. Legislation to legalize mixed martial arts died last June in the Assembly’s Committee on Tourism, Arts and Sports Development. Assemblyman Bob Reilly, a Democrat from the Albany area, took the floor to excoriate what he called a “disgusting” spectacle.
“I spoke for about three or five minutes without any intention of swaying votes,” Mr. Reilly said in an interview. But his argument that such “brutal and violent” events had no place in the state resonated with the majority, which prevented the bill from moving to the floor for consideration by the full Assembly.
To bolster its case, the Ultimate Fighting Championship released in November an economic impact study claiming that mixed martial arts events would have “a significant impact on state and local economies by generating tax revenues, creating jobs and boosting tourism industries.”
“It’s about education, I believe,” said Marc Ratner, the association’s vice president of government and regulatory affairs. “The sport will never be acceptable to 100 percent of the population. There are people who don’t like N.F.L. football. It’s personal taste. To say that it’s not right for the state to me is very wrong.”
Mr. Ratner said that the sport had changed considerably since former Gov. George E. Pataki called it “barbaric” and pushed for the ban in 1997. It is now legal in 37 of 45 states that have athletic commissions, he said. Most states operate under a set of unified rules of mixed martial arts, first adopted by New Jersey in 2000, which establish weight classes, rounds and more than two dozen types of fouls. Only one serious injury, a broken arm, has occurred in the roughly 800 Ultimate Fighting Championship fights that have been held in Nevada since 2001, Mr. Ratner said.
But Mr. Reilly, a former running coach at Siena College, points to the unified rules as one of the reasons he continues to support the ban. The sport, for example, allows fist and elbow strikes to the head while an opponent is on the ground. “I find the rules themselves speak against the sport and make a clear statement that the purpose of the fight is not to demonstrate skills but to damage your opponent,” he said.
Supporters respond that the sport attracts gifted athletes who are dedicated to true competition. Fourteen former Olympians and 17 former college wrestling champions have participated in mixed martial arts, the association says.
“They are serious, educated and passionate about what they do,” said Christian Montes, a professional fighter who operates Ronin Athletics, a mixed martial arts school on West 37th Street in Manhattan.
Advocates argue that legalization could marginalize fringe aspects of the sport. Peter Storm, promoter of what he calls the Underground Combat League, has been hosting unregulated matches in isolated locations in the city. “My shows attract fans of the sport who don’t want to go to Jersey and would rather see a fight live rather than on pay-per-view,” he said.
Bryan Vetell, 31, a professional fighter from Briarwood, Queens, said he started his career in underground matches. “There was no weigh-in, no gloves, no medical reports, no warm-ups, no nothing,” he said. “But that’s what we had to work with in New York City.”
Ending unregulated fights is one reason that Melvina Lathan, a veteran boxing judge who was appointed chairwoman of the New York State Athletic Commission in July, supports lifting the ban. “The safety aspect is a particular concern of mine,” she said.
Legislators in Albany said that a bill on mixed martial arts would probably not come up for a vote until the end of this session, which winds up in June. Members of the Assembly’s tourism committee remain divided, said Assemblyman Steve Englebright, a Democrat from Suffolk County. “I don’t think it’s shaken its image as human c0ckfighting, not among all the members of the committee,” he said.
A Senate committee did not consider a similar bill during the last session. A spokeswoman for Governor Paterson said he would not comment on the issue until a bill was passed by both chambers of the Legislature.
Carmine Zocchi, a professional fighter and instructor from Middle Village, Queens, said New York should be a showcase for mixed martial arts. “New York is supposed to be the center of the world, and it has nothing,” he said. “I have to travel four hours to fight. Why not have it in Madison Square Garden? Can you imagine how crazy that would be? It would be insane.”
A version of this article appeared in print on January 21, 2009, on page A28 of the New York edition.