To cut a long story short, Mr Punch's question was addressed to me and not anyone else. So to say that it was a general question is a LIE! I see the same pattern again Mr Chris!Originally Posted by cjurakpt
As far as CFT is concerned, I personally took it to mean dantien breathings relevance to combat. However, even if it wasn't, I doubt that he wanted an explication of dantien breathing on the "cellular" level.
And then SoCoKungFu, who is in the medical profession himself and god help the person whose life depends on him. You could have PM-ed him your monologue.
You went over the top with your explanation. Listen, most of the knuckleheads here have only mastered the Western Breathing method just because it keeps them alive. A simple combat related piece of one paragraph would have been fine.
If you look at my various posts on the subject then you will see what it is that I mean. Of course I am referring to the posts other than the ones addressed to your cognitively challenged forum friend, unkokusai.
Not necessarilly!
I understand what you are saying, but what is your point (besides demonstrating your knowledge, when I didn't ask for it). Look there are many types of chi kung. Hard/Soft "normal/reverse" etc. There are chi kung aspects and exercises that none of us will ever get to know. So what is your point? The man asked how I breath and I explained.
Sarcasm? Belittling?is this an attempt at sarcasm / belittling in order to generate some sort of emotional response on my part?
Do you always "misunderstand" when people try to help you expand your knowledge by teaching you things that you don't know?
I am suggesting that you may not know all that you think you know. Actually you don't!
I don't know if your sifu is good or bad or if he was good then wether he taught you all you needed to know. I am not talking about therapy but KUNG FU!
Not really. My opinion of your training is based on your own comments regarding kung fu in other threads.
I have tried "reasoned" discussion with you before, at your request I might add. I seem to remember that you referred to it as being "civil". You know how long that lasted don't you. I know that you are no real kung fu exponent and what little your sifu taught you doesn't include morals or humility.
Well with that attitude of yours, I am not going to teach anything either.
Yes, I can see how.
After all I did not manage to take a simple KUNG FU based question and turn it into an unending d1ck waving monologue that chased away the posters that even unkokusai hadn't managed to scare off.
Believe me there is, but you wouldn't understand it. People like you never understand chi kung or indeed kung fu fully and that is because to understand them, you have to have the ability to see the wood for the trees. And that skill I know that your sifu never taught you!
Again, another example of, "hey look, I know this and I know that, how about you".
In our Wing Chun school our power issuance comes from breathing the way described before and "sinking", combined with relaxed body unity.
I wont go into the specifics of the exercises, as those are not discussed outside the school, but I suppose you can classify as "reverse", ie. breath out and expand.
Because I have seen you being "civil" starting with your first post addressed to me through to the "famous" and ugly prank in which you participated.
Then don't worry about irritating them, let them worry.
Relevant to combat? Yes, keep on dreaming.
Unkokusai is one of your mentaly disturbed knucklehead forum buddies and wherever he goes he causes trouble. Maybe you should treat him. You know, stick needles in him or something, preferably in his eyes.
That unkokusai again! you sure keep interesting company. At least we don't have to deal with other fakes such as Sanjuro, who has apparently got me on ignore since the day I exposed his lies.
However, we both know that he doesn't have his ignore button on, just like you didn't have yours on when you briefly pretended to have me on ignore, YET MORE LIES and falsehoods dished out by both of you "civil" people.
And I have explained about those questions. However, the next time someone asks a basic question, try and give a BASIC (and relevant) answer.
Don't humor me, we both know that the range of the topics were not "wide" enough for your monologue.
AND someone who mentions weight lifting!! Hooray!! Finally a practical response to researching Chi! Skeletal, muscle and tendon alignment to produce the desired effect!! Whether that be longevity or muscle mass, it's all the same fme.
Lee Shing was known for having sets to practice Hei Gung, but nothing will do a better job than the forms themselves imo.
