Originally Posted by
chusauli
I took this out of the boxing vs. WCK thread and created a new thread.
Victor, an advanced practitioner like you should already know the benefits of structure, so I assume you are playing Devil's Advocate. The benefits are:
1) Power
2) Leverage
3) to use the body optimally in unison or in parts
4) Non-telegraphic delivery system
5) control of the opponent's balance
6) opening of the "door" through pushing, pulling, wedging (i.e like pummeling, you set up your next moves)
7) my system is easily replicable/duplicable, hence "scientific"
8) I don't just talk one part (i.e. elbows) but look at the organism as a whole
9) my system doesn't change any WCK forms, just makes them better
10) my methodology fits in with all branches of WCK, since it is not based on form, As Hawkins said to me, "True WCK is formless."
11) Its not about the show or "style", or how it looks like, but the power signature
12) there is a great advantage with weapons, for example, you learn to properly use the body in conjunction with the long pole or knives - you need proper levelage when doing Tiu Gwun or Yee Ji Dao
13) Application is your guide - so which opponent are you applying structure to? That is your work, not mine. In fact, that is every WCK student's work.
14) you can use body structure greatly against people with little or no structure; you will be the one in control. Of course, against equals, it becomes a contest of who is the one who uses it best at the moment
15) I do not have to had Muay Thai, Boixing, or BJJ delivery base to make it work, making it a pseudo WCK or JKD. I keep WCK pure - it is about making WCK work.
16) In most WCK you learn structure, but its more about the shape and looking like WCK...not necessarily the function of the structure
In my way, you are studying how to apply structure, make it work, and test it out - this way, you optimally use WCK
Its quite possible everyone in WCK can use my methods and keep their style, or even learn my method without having to learn WCK forms and system, just merge it with their fighting style.
In Traditional Chinese Martial arts, 1 component represents the complete teaching, one does not not having to learn everything piecemeal. I can teach 3 things that would change your perspective immediately. Even if you did not learn all of my curriculum and teaching methodology, you could still use my method immediately.
Finally, when you develop something "new", you don't just throw a name on it (a la JKD), you have to test it. My students and grandstudents have tested it out using my templates in the competition arena. In this way, we know it works.