詠春係一個家庭
Do you mean the chi sao part or the pre-contact part? In the pre-contact I was simply demonstrating moves from the dummy.Originally Posted by Graham H
Would I do it that way if someone was really trying to hit me? Who knows. It would depend on many X-factors.
I do know the difference between a demo where everything works perfect and dealing with a resisting opponent. Remember, I did do full contact. That was a demo.
詠春係一個家庭
This statement is what's wrong with many WC people. There are bad dudes in all lineages. There are people not so good in all lineages. I know some great fighters in many lineages.. . . . I used to do things like that in the Ip Chun lineage. I left thankfully when somebody from the WSL lineage kicked my sorry @ss.
GH
It's the man fighting. Not the lineage.
Registered User
Im from the Ip Chun lineage, the school I go to does throw realisitc punches at one and another.we actually try to hit each other. Then you realize what works and what doesn't.
I used to do things like that in the Ip Chun lineage. I left thankfully when somebody from the WSL lineage kicked my sorry @ss.
GH
Maybe you went to a poor school.
Registered User
PhilThis statement is what's wrong with many WC people. There are bad dudes in all lineages. There are people not so good in all lineages. I know some great fighters in many lineages.
It's the man fighting. Not the lineage.
I agree.
S.O
Yes I did go to a poor school.
GH
Registered User
Then shouldnt speak about the Ip Chun linege in a bad way when you admit your last school was poor.
madness
Registered User
SO
It was poor because it was Ip Chun lineage. I'll refer back to Phils statement that all lineages have people that can fight but as far as Ip Chun system goes..........................................bleu rgh!!!!!
I tried 4 different schools so you can't say I didn't persevere with it. Just giving an honest opinion. I'm entitled to that.
I also met Ip Chun twice. Once in UK and once in HK. I got very annoyed as he requested to be addressed as The Master.........Master of what???? So I asked him about Ip Man instead.
In fact I remember one school in HK where a very respected Teacher on this forum put a video of Ip Chun on performing Bil Jee and I sat there and watched him and all his students laugh at it like it was some sort of comedy dance.
The weird and wonderful world of WCK as always.
GH
Registered User
maybe your school didnt have a great relationship with him???SO
It was poor because it was Ip Chun lineage. I'll refer back to Phils statement that all lineages have people that can fight but as far as Ip Chun system goes..........................................bleu rgh!!!!!
I tried 4 different schools so you can't say I didn't persevere with it. Just giving an honest opinion. I'm entitled to that.
I also met Ip Chun twice. Once in UK and once in HK. I got very annoyed as he requested to be addressed as The Master.........Master of what???? So I asked him about Ip Man instead.
In fact I remember one school in HK where a very respected Teacher on this forum put a video of Ip Chun on performing Bil Jee and I sat there and watched him and all his students laugh at it like it was some sort of comedy dance.
The weird and wonderful world of WCK as always.
GH
each to his own and all and I suppose your allowed your opinion, but you wouldnt catch me turning my nose up at what other people do.
Ive met him a few times and everytime he has been a gent.
could you post this video of him doing BJ please or pm to me
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote