Originally Posted by
IronFist
You're still missing the point.
It only matters if other people are "sackless/spineless dweebs" if they are making claims themselves.
I'm not a very good singer, but I can tell you when professional singers miss notes. I don't have to be a better singer than them to be correct in identifying when they are sharp/flat.
If RWilson was talking about being a qigong master, breaking the bottom brick with qi (rather than with physics), catching bullets in his teeth, etc., but failing to show any proof, then sure, he's open to ridicule.
If RWilson is saying he's better than people at certain things but failing to show any proof, then sure, call him a "sackless/spineless dweeb."
Your "my door is always open" attitude is fine, but it doesn't prove anything you've said or disprove anything anyone else is saying.
Some people just don't seem to grasp that.
If someone says they can do
x, and they want other people to believe that they can do
x, then it is up to them to demonstrate that they can do
x.
Dale seems to want this forum to believe so badly that he's a bad ass. The only other person I've seen get that p*ssed off when questioned was Ashida Kim! And naturally so, because Ashida Kim had no skills to prove so his entire business was based on people believing he was a ninja.
The only people who believed Ashida were little kids who wanted to believe they were learning secret ninja tricks.
And the ironic part is I don't even think Dale is a fake or anything like Ashida Kim is, it just seems that his ego is too tied up in what this forum thinks about him.
And I agree with the person who said posting a push hands vid is not a demonstration of fighting ability against a resisting opponent.
Dale has posted a lot of vids, so lets give him credit for that.
Dale has posted iron palm vids. I'm going to believe him that they are legit and he's not cooking the bricks or anything. He probably has good iron palm development.
Dale has posted breaking the bottom brick vids. I'm going to believe him that they are legit and he's not up to any funny business (even though the bottom brick is a different color). But as pointed out numerous times, this is 100% physics and 0% qigong powers. He's not projecting his qi through the first brick and into the bottom brick. As pointed out before, this has been done with a hammer, too (the vid was posted here before but I can't find it on YouTube at the moment). Or if you want, you can put a very small peble over the bottom brick. Or match sticks.
Dale has posted vids of walking the circle with kettlebells and also with a weight vest while holding two kettlebells overhead. He seems to be in pretty good shape, especially for a bigger guy. Most people probably couldn't do that. But that has nothing to do with fighting ability, nor is anything in that video transferrable to fighting. And before everyone here jizzes their pants at his strength, Dale is a big guy and probably weighs at least 250lbs. Those are 50 pound kettlebells according to the video description. That means each kettlebell is, at most 1/5 of Dale's weight. So that is equivalent to a skinny 150 pound KFM forum nerd or, as Dale likes to call them, "spineless/sackless dweebs," using 30 pound kettlebells, which would be quite easy with a bit of training.
Dale has posted vids of people throwing McDojo punches at him in an iron body demo. The backfist at 0:21 is especially laughable. Is this iron body development or just people smaller than him half assing their strikes? Or are you going to tell me that those were qi-laden strikes that would kill a lesser man?
Dale appears to have decent physical conditioning but that vid is nothing that a mid level MMA guy couldn't do, even without "iron body" training.
To claim that that was "qi" protecting him from those strikes would be laughable, but I give Dale props in that vid for not standing stationary in a horse stance and doing qigong exercises to "build his protective qi" and the other nonsense that you usually see in those vids.
None of these vids have anything to do with fighting ability, however. They just indicate that Dale appears to be in decent shape and very good shape for a TMAist.
Under the same account that has all the videos of Dale is a video of John Painter moving some guy without touching him. Maybe this is high level ability that Dale hasn't achieved yet. And I'm pretty sure that opponent wasn't resisting.
Last edited by I Hate Ashida Kim; 07-12-2012 at 10:03 PM.
"If Ashida wished you to know his real name, I am sure he would write to you and tell you himself." --Danny Sainty
"So, you supposed martial artists, what are you trining for? Who are you training to fight? Apparently no one. Because even in a hypothetical situation, you puss out, Ha! Ha!" --Ashida Kim