The issue is the same in this thread as any other "qi" thread:
No one has defined Qi to a point that all agree on.
Untill Qi is defined, then it can be discussed in any serious form.
This is a MA forum and as such, any discussion about Qi should relate to the MA application of them and, for those that prefer ( for whatever twisted reason) to do MA as a form of "exercise" then there can be a discussion about QI as it relates to health.
But you have to make a call in regards to which "view" of Qi you want to discuss.
Psalms 144:1
Praise be my Lord my Rock,
He trains my hands for war, my fingers for battle !