Link to the wc ancestors

[Vajramusti]

What a surprise, a thread about someones vague cryptic (and somewhat smug at this stage) question and its well into its 5th page with no end in sight

Moshe, how well can you fight with your style?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
I was open minded, Now I have seen and read enough. Some things were interesting-but enough is enough for me anyway.

[WC1277]

My speed in replying to posts has caused mistakes on numerous ocassions but now I feel silly for thinking you may even know the answer to your own question Jox!...

Wait, is Moshe and Jox the same person?

[Vajramusti]

Wait, is Moshe and Jox the same person?

-----------------------------------------------
No, I don;t think so.Spencer's typo.

[MOSHE]

Moshe, how well can you fight with your style?

i have 3 sec to hurt any kind of opponent , and its not easy to block my arm when i launch it to attack

saying that ,im not speaking about a boxing punch

and if you mean fighting like kick boxing or free fighting ,i have no interest in that .

its not relevant to the practice of original wing chun ,i received and counter productive

[GlennR]

i have 3 sec to hurt any kind of opponent , and its not easy to block my arm when i launch it to attack

saying that ,im not speaking about a boxing punch

and if you mean fighting like kick boxing or free fighting ,i have no interest in that .

its not relevant to the practice of original wing chun ,i received and counter productive

How do you test it?

[MOSHE]

How do you test it?

against other people for example !

i have to say again , that im not practising shi sao in an extensive way ,last time Jox came to train with me ,i did chi sao with him for the first time since 6 months before

working the right way with the dummy is the key tool

chi sao for yip man was just to keep people busy like today some sifu are taking one third on the time during the class to do cardio training

chi sao is just for beginners

[GlennR]

against other people for example !

Yeh but how? Sparring, organised fights? death matches?

i have to say again , that im not practising shi sao in an extensive way ,last time Jox came to train with me ,i did chi sao with him for the first time since 6 months before

working the right way with the dummy is the key tool

chi sao for yip man was just to keep people busy like today some sifu are taking one third on the time during the class to do cardio training

chi sao is just for beginners

You have a high opinion of your lineage and yourself, how have you come to this conclusion?

[MOSHE]

Yeh but how? Sparring, organised fights? death matches?



You have a high opinion of your lineage and yourself, how have you come to this conclusion?

Not of myself
I went trough differents styles and even before to meet my last sifu
I learned two other wing Chun lineages (not yip man)
I met differents practitioners

I finally made the choice of the best potential ,the more efficient and authentic

[GlennR]

Not of myself
I went trough differents styles and even before to meet my last sifu
I learned two other wing Chun lineages (not yip man)
I met differents practitioners

I finally made the choice of the best potential ,the more efficient and authentic

Yes, but how have you tested it?

[wingchunIan]

You see that you understood my question , but you simply failed to answer

actually I think the answer was very complete, you just lack the ability to understand it.

[MOSHE]

Yes, but how have you tested it?

Contact,,,,

[GlennR]

Contact,,,,

God, i give up

Congrats on creating the longest, most pointless threads here, and thats saying something!

[wingchunIan]

chi sao is just for beginners

In that single line you have summed up your ignorance of the system. Chi sao is a vital part of the system developig and honing reflexes , it's at least on a par with the dummy, the wall bag, drilling and application work (whether you call it sparring or pressure testing or whatever) as you become more proficient so the exercise evolves and you continue to learn and hone your skills.
Good luck with your training and if you ever get attacked by a wooden post with three arms and only one leg I'm sure you'll do well.

[MOSHE]

In that single line you have summed up your ignorance of the system. Chi sao is a vital part of the system developig and honing reflexes , it's at least on a par with the dummy, the wall bag, drilling and application work (whether you call it sparring or pressure testing or whatever) as you become more proficient so the exercise evolves and you continue to learn and hone your skills.
Good luck with your training and if you ever get attacked by a wooden post with three arms and only one leg I'm sure you'll do well.

Yes mister 5% of what I know and can do

[GlennR]

Yes mister 5% of what I know and can do

All you seem to know well is to create pointless threads with no ending.... well done