Is This Really VT?

[Happy Tiger]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XQ0j53-0zE
Is this really VT? It seems more like I Kuen....or something.Weird

[Vajramusti]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XQ0j53-0zE
Is this really VT? It seems more like I Kuen....or something.Weird

-------------------------------------------
Not very good.non Ip Man wing chun-the "rolling: shows that.
-

[lance]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XQ0j53-0zE
Is this really VT? It seems more like I Kuen....or something.Weird

Happy Tiger , this is the first time I ever saw chi sao done this way , but my guess is that these people made up this type of chi sao , the first movement looks like tai chi version of chi sao , the second movement looks like they made it up . This is the way I see it .

[LFJ]

Of course because only Yip Man knew real VT and he took that to HK, right?

[k gledhill]

They are all wrists no elbows.

[wingchunIan]

personally not my cup of tea but who can say whether they have the original secret recipe or a made up recent invention.

[guy b.]

-------------------------------------------
Not very good.non Ip Man wing chun-the "rolling: shows that.
-

News flash: most wing chun is sh1t

[Graham H]

news flash: Most wing chun is sh1t

Yes you are right.

[Wayfaring]

-------------------------------------------
Not very good.non Ip Man wing chun-the "rolling: shows that.
-

Plenty of non Ip Man wing chun that doesn't distort stances like that or produce that kind of sway.

[markfreedom]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XQ0j53-0zE
Is this really VT? It seems more like I Kuen....or something.Weird

Yes, this is Ving Tsun. I know that because it is my video. This is one variation of what has become known as "Mainland Style" WC/VT.

I was a partner in the school until my health went bad and I had to return to the states.

More info will be available as I have returned to my channel with a video blog and will soon be posting more videos of my old school.

[markfreedom]

Happy Tiger , this is the first time I ever saw chi sao done this way , but my guess is that these people made up this type of chi sao , the first movement looks like tai chi version of chi sao , the second movement looks like they made it up . This is the way I see it .

They are not Chi Sao. They are training. The first trains your body and lower back to duck. That one saved several of my teeth once. The second one is for lower arm control.

[Hendrik]

This is a traditional Wck.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9XQ0j53-0zE
Is this really VT? It seems more like I Kuen....or something.Weird

[Happy Tiger]

Interesting.Loose as a goose.

[Eric_H]

no centerline = no wing chun.

[PalmStriker]

Best to let Mark post one of the school's Chi Sao clips to see that there is familiar ground.