Is the modern Wck structure and chi sau a problem in reality?

[Hendrik]

Is the modern Wck structure and chi sau platform evolution from ancient the circle chi sau platform is a problem in reality?

What is your view?

[Hendrik]

This chi sau and Wck structure holding seems to tell the story of an evolution into a long fist art.

[Hendrik]

IMHO, the above is the root of the issue of this thread.

IMHO, this evolution of Wck as in the YouTube doesn't work facing western boxing .


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXzzg2ZnTMc

http://www.kungfumagazine.com/forum/...50#post1265350

[LFJ]

Is the modern Wck structure and Luk sau chi sau platform evolution from ancient the circle chi sau platform is a problem in reality?

In reality? It's for development. We don't actually fight in this position with both arms extended.

[Hendrik]

General Modern Wck chi sau end up this way

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mL9Z...=youtube_gdata

[Hendrik]

In reality? It's for development. We don't actually fight in this position with both arms extended.

Then, why train it this way ? What skill does one develop beside programmed into stuck ness?

[LFJ]

Then, why train it this way ? What skill does one develop beside programmed into stuck ness?

It's not a 1on1 match. It's an exchange of force to develop various attributes. That's all. One will not be mal-programmed as long as they have the right idea and are free sparring.