Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 21

Thread: 7 Star vs Plum Blossom Mantis- similarities and differences?

  1. #1

    7 Star vs Plum Blossom Mantis- similarities and differences?

    Hi,

    I have the opportunity to study both Seven Star and Plum Blossom mantis from two different teachers in my area.

    Could someone with experience and/or knowledge in both systems highlight some of the similarities and differences?

    I'm especially interested in how much legwork and twisting/jumping each does, as I have a bum knee and would need to modify those components considerably.

    Thanks in advance

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    North Canton, OH
    Posts
    1,848
    Quote Originally Posted by Fenghuang View Post
    Hi,

    I have the opportunity to study both Seven Star and Plum Blossom mantis from two different teachers in my area.

    Could someone with experience and/or knowledge in both systems highlight some of the similarities and differences?

    I'm especially interested in how much legwork and twisting/jumping each does, as I have a bum knee and would need to modify those components considerably.

    Thanks in advance
    I have trained with two Seven Star shifu and two Taiji Meihua shifu. I believe both families have very effective martial arts techniques. I feel very privileged to have studied in both families of tanglangquan.

    IN GENERAL:

    Hong Kong Seven Star uses higher stances, than the Plum Flower families. Yet it also uses more leaping kicks in the forms, than the Plum Flower families. As an old **** with bad knees and arthritis in my ankles, I find the Plum Flower stances much harder to endure. Yet I prefer the Plum Flower forms over the Hong Kong Seven Star forms.

    Plum Flower families emphasize more waist movement, than Hong Kong Seven Star. Some accuse Hong Kong Seven Star as being "all arms". Though I don't necessarily agree with that, I do see how they can get that impression.

    Who are the instructors in your area?
    Last edited by mooyingmantis; 08-30-2014 at 04:53 PM.
    Richard A. Tolson
    https://www.patreon.com/mantismastersacademy

    There are two types of Chinese martial artists. Those who can fight and those who should be teaching dance or yoga!

    53 years of training, 43 years of teaching and still aiming for perfection!

    Recovering Forms Junkie! Even my twelve step program has four roads!

  3. #3
    Quote Originally Posted by mooyingmantis View Post
    I have trained with two Seven Star shifu and two Taiji Meihua shifu. I believe both families have very effective martial arts techniques. I feel very privileged to have studied in both families of tanglangquan.

    IN GENERAL:

    Hong Kong Seven Star uses higher stances, than the Plum Flower families. Yet it also uses more leaping kicks in the forms, than the Plum Flower families. As an old **** with bad knees and arthritis in my ankles, I find the Plum Flower stances much harder to endure. Yet I prefer the Plum Flower forms over the Hong Kong Seven Star forms.

    Plum Flower families emphasize more waist movement, than Hong Kong Seven Star. Some accuse Hong Kong Seven Star as being "all arms". Though I don't necessarily agree with that, I do see how they can get that impression.

    Who are the instructors in your area?
    Dear Moonyingmantis,

    Thank you for the informative reply. I have sent you a private message regarding your question.

    Best,
    Fenghuang

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    North Canton, OH
    Posts
    1,848

    Compare& Contrast

    I thought it might be interesting to compare and contrast some commonly practiced techniques found in both the Hong Kong Seven Star and Mainland Plum Flower Mantis families.

    Please note that I am speaking in generalities and not hard, fast rules.

    1. The popular principle 勾 搂 采 - hook, hold and pluck in Seven Star is known as 拉 封 打 - pull, seal & strike in Plum Flower.

    2. The waist chop in Seven Star is often performed from the Seven Star step, while it is often performed from a Small Mountain Climbing stance in Plum Flower forms

    3. In both lines, 崩 捶 - a crashing strike is often preceded by a 圈 捶 - circle/hook strike.

    4. In both lines, 腰 斬 - the waist chop is often preceded by 崩 捶 - a crashing strike.

    5. In both lines, 崩 捶 - a crashing strike often precedes 鴛 鴦 腳 - a mandarin duck kick/lead roundhouse kick with retreat.

    Just a few examples.
    Last edited by mooyingmantis; 09-06-2014 at 11:13 AM.
    Richard A. Tolson
    https://www.patreon.com/mantismastersacademy

    There are two types of Chinese martial artists. Those who can fight and those who should be teaching dance or yoga!

    53 years of training, 43 years of teaching and still aiming for perfection!

    Recovering Forms Junkie! Even my twelve step program has four roads!

  5. #5
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Shanghai, China
    Posts
    245
    Seven Star Mantis has a strong Long Fist influence.... even more so with the lineages which came through Hong Kong. The movements tend to be longer and more linear.

    Meihua (and Taiji) Mantis uses more circular movements, tending to be closer range and using elbows and shoulders slightly more.

    The similarities are greater than the differences, its mostly just in which forms are practiced, and the height of stances as Richard mentioned, as well as the focus on larger or smaller frame.

    Richard.... about your point number 2: I have found it to be the other way round in Yantai/Qingdao... Taiji/meihua uses the hooked foot for waist chop more, whereas Seven Star uses the mountain climbing step.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    Shell Beach, CA, USA
    Posts
    6,664
    Blog Entries
    16
    Quote Originally Posted by Fenghuang View Post
    highlight some of the similarities and differences?
    My understand is the

    - 7 star mantis likes to use the 7 star stance. It will give you better "leg control".
    - Meihua mantis likes to use the monkey stance. It will give you more "mobility".

    Quote Originally Posted by xiao yao View Post
    Taiji/meihua uses the hooked foot for waist chop more, whereas Seven Star uses the mountain climbing step.
    Since the 7 star stance has better leg control, I think the 7 star mantis will use hooked foot more than the Meihua mantis. As far as I know, both styles all use the following leg skills in "waist chop".

    - mountain climbing stance,
    - 7 star stance (mantis call this "little knock"),
    - foot sweep.
    Last edited by YouKnowWho; 09-21-2014 at 09:29 PM.
    http://johnswang.com

    More opinion -> more argument
    Less opinion -> less argument
    No opinion -> no argument

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Jan 1970
    Location
    SF Bay Area
    Posts
    2,111
    Quote Originally Posted by mooyingmantis View Post
    2. The waist chop in Seven Star is often performed from the Seven Star step, while it is often performed from a Small Mountain Climbing stance in Plum Flower forms
    Quote Originally Posted by xiao yao View Post
    Richard.... about your point number 2: I have found it to be the other way round in Yantai/Qingdao... Taiji/meihua uses the hooked foot for waist chop more, whereas Seven Star uses the mountain climbing step.
    Quote Originally Posted by YouKnowWho View Post
    As far as I know, both styles all use the following leg skills in "waist chop".

    - mountain climbing stance,
    - 7 star stance (mantis call this "little knock"),
    - foot sweep.
    That is quite a range of observations.

    I can speak only from the Northern Mantis perspective of WHF line.

    7 star step, mountain climbing step, and small mountain climbing step(link step or circle entering step) are all used with waist chop.

    You can look at the three steps as a continuum going from 7 star, to mountain climbing, to small mountain climbing.

    7 star emphasizes the waist chop throw earlier in the engagement of the footwork.

    Mountain climbing has greater depth of control and coordination with your own body's center of mass for the throw.

    Small mountain climbing coordinates spiraling sinking force and added momentum to the throw from mountain climbing step.

    WHF Mantis is considered a combination of 7 Star, Plum Blossum, and Spotless Mantis.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jan 1970
    Location
    SF Bay Area
    Posts
    2,111
    Quote Originally Posted by YouKnowWho View Post
    - 7 star mantis likes to use the 7 star stance. It will give you better "leg control".
    I don't know if the leg control is better, but it is earlier when starting at range. And allows fast transition for followup movement/attack with the rear leg.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    North Canton, OH
    Posts
    1,848
    Quote Originally Posted by -N- View Post
    Small mountain climbing coordinates spiraling sinking force and added momentum to the throw from mountain climbing step.
    Great description!
    Richard A. Tolson
    https://www.patreon.com/mantismastersacademy

    There are two types of Chinese martial artists. Those who can fight and those who should be teaching dance or yoga!

    53 years of training, 43 years of teaching and still aiming for perfection!

    Recovering Forms Junkie! Even my twelve step program has four roads!

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    Shell Beach, CA, USA
    Posts
    6,664
    Blog Entries
    16
    Quote Originally Posted by -N- View Post
    I don't know if the leg control is better, but it is earlier when starting at range. And allows fast transition for followup movement/attack with the rear leg.
    This is the "leg control" by using 7 star stance that I'm talking about.

    Name:  Chang_leg_seize1.jpg
Views: 857
Size:  13.3 KB

    Here is the 3 waist chops by using the

    - bow-arrow stance,
    - 7 star stance, and
    - foot sweep,

    in the 7 star mantis.

    http://johnswang.com

    More opinion -> more argument
    Less opinion -> less argument
    No opinion -> no argument

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    Shell Beach, CA, USA
    Posts
    6,664
    Blog Entries
    16
    Quote Originally Posted by -N- View Post
    Small mountain climbing coordinates spiraling sinking force and added momentum to the throw from mountain climbing step.
    Is the "small mountain climbing" similar to the Shuai-Chiao "挤桩 - squeeze"?

    http://johnswang.com

    More opinion -> more argument
    Less opinion -> less argument
    No opinion -> no argument

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Jan 2003
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    768
    Quote Originally Posted by YouKnowWho View Post
    Is the "small mountain climbing" similar to the Shuai-Chiao "挤桩 - squeeze"?

    Close, but without lifting the heel.

    BT

  13. #13
    Join Date
    May 2011
    Location
    Shanghai, China
    Posts
    245
    The technique Waist Chop (yao zhan) is just one variation of the technique "Mantis Hands, Jade Ring Step" (tanglang shou, yuhuan bu), which is an important basic technique, and one of the 8 stances.

    In Waist Chop you grab the opponents left wrist with your left hand (or grab their face if no wrist is grabable), pull it to the left, placing the left hook foot behind the opponents ankle (or can sweep up), and then use the right hand to chop/push at their right ribs.

    The variation which uses Small Mountain Climbing Step (xiao deng shan bu) is called Yuhuan Shou (jade ring hands) or Mopan Shou (grind/coil hands). In this technique you step in more aggressively, making contact shin to shin, grab the opponents neck/face and pull it to the left, however you make contact along the whole of your arm to the shoulder, using Kao power to throw the opponent. Yuhuan Shou and Mo Pan Shou only differ in that the first one you twist to 45*, the second to 90*, having a different effect on how the opponent falls.

    At least this is how it is in Taiji Mantis.... I cant speak for others.....

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    Shell Beach, CA, USA
    Posts
    6,664
    Blog Entries
    16
    Most of the mantis "waist chop" is to use

    - leading leg control,
    - back arm pull.

    Sometime it's easier to use

    - back leg control,
    - leading arm pull.

    The reason is simple. You will have better chance to pull your opponent's leading arm than to pull his back arm. The trade off is you have to extend your control leg a bit further to reach to his back leg.

    Also the hand "chop" to the waist can be use on the elbow joint pull. By using 2 arms to pull 1 arm is always better than to use 1 arm to pull 1 arm. Your intention is to throw your opponent and not to kill him with your chop on his waist.
    Last edited by YouKnowWho; 09-27-2014 at 12:13 PM.
    http://johnswang.com

    More opinion -> more argument
    Less opinion -> less argument
    No opinion -> no argument

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Nov 2005
    Location
    North Canton, OH
    Posts
    1,848
    Quote Originally Posted by xiao yao View Post
    The variation which uses Small Mountain Climbing Step.... In this technique you step in more aggressively, making contact shin to shin...At least this is how it is in Taiji Mantis.... I cant speak for others.....
    In our school, rather than making contact shin to shin, we step in deeper. My left hip contacts the enemy's right hip and I chop the enemy's waist with my right palm to throw him over my left thigh. Thus, the technique is not a trip, but rather a throw. The enemy falls from a greater height which increases his chances of being hurt more seriously.

    Here is my student Dominic Marazita demonstrating the waist chop in a form:

    Richard A. Tolson
    https://www.patreon.com/mantismastersacademy

    There are two types of Chinese martial artists. Those who can fight and those who should be teaching dance or yoga!

    53 years of training, 43 years of teaching and still aiming for perfection!

    Recovering Forms Junkie! Even my twelve step program has four roads!

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •