Sifu James McNeil

[Dragon Fire]

Has anyone ever heard of this guy? Is he a legitimate(sp?) teacher? I have an opportunity to train under one of his students. Thanks in advance.

[Stranger]

Sorry about telling you to post this here and then getting no responses.

There are old threads here (on the tai chi board)about McNeil.

I don't get mad.
I get stabby.

[TheBigToad]

I might get hell for this but James McNeil is pretty decent. He isn't a slacker and had the same Hsing-I teacher Mike Patterson did, he knows his fighting applications.

I am the big toad and this is my pond.

[Stranger]

Come on. There has to be more input on him.
Thanks Kevin.

I don't get mad.
I get stabby.

[razakdigital]

I have a tape of McNeil and I read some interviews. From what I saw he looks like a good fighter. He might not have the most fluid form but you can tell when someone knows their stuff. He alignment and structure is good. One of our clan elders is a Hsing fighter and he is in Cali. He stated (from my understanding) that the guy has power and is the real deal. (as everyone knows we don't impressed easily by anyone)

I'm just a mere mortal when it comes to learning Hsing-I. I think you have to know what you are looking for. If you looking for hsing-i forms, there many good websites to get some nice wushu forms. ( I have a lot of them). But there are (from my research) a few people that can really use Hsing-I to the fullest. I hope to be one of them.

[blkbelt65]

The guy is useless. Check out his tapes. He's a joke. A buddy of mine asked him why he advertises that his tapes teach kicking, when they teach NONE at all and he sent him a VIRUS. Can you believe that crap!!!??? Yeah, that's something I would look for in a teacher. Pure ignorance!

[fiercest tiger]

A friend of mine had is splashing hands tape, i didnt think much of him as a fighter though, maybe an artist! bullsh!t artist..lol

[dfedorko@mindspring.com]

My experiences with James McNeil are only with video and magazines. In the early 80's he had an Iron Palm video which I thought, at the time, was very good. His demonstration looked very good to me, a beginner. It gave me the foundation to begin Iron Palm training. Then I purchased both of his Chen videos which, I thought, were great. He lauded his lao shr in these two videos which was great. I purchased his tape on a Shaolin Staff and, again, I thought it was pretty good. But, when I saw an article in "Inside Kung Fu" magazine, a picture of him trying to break a watermelon, I lost some respect for him. The Japanese do it better.

xiaotiema

[Water Dragon]

I've heard his skills are legitamate. Sounds like another case of a solid practitioner losing credibility due to his courting of the Qi Heads. IMO, it's a shame.

[Internal Boxer]

Water Dragon I am with you mate, I cannot understand why everyone seems focused on critising teacher after teacher, so blo.ody what if he tried to do whatever with a fr.iggin water melon, I have never trained with Mcneil and cannot pass comment but others do not hold themselves back when just looking through a magazine they draw conclusions on ability, but to me that only mirrors their own lack of understanding.

For instance there seems to be a lot of Erle critics, but having been to his seminars I have seen and felt this guys power and I can 100% say he has it. Over the years I have done all the full contact sparring and so on, but the power Erle has is serious sh.it, and he does not express it these days which does pi.ss me off as it will answer these nobodies who waffle on about pathetic things like tassles making noises come on guys lets get REAL.

I am getting very tired of people just disrespecting others without actualling going to see them personally to see if they have ability. Let me give you some advice - go see them before you cast judgement on them: This is prejudice pure and simple.

[CD Lee]

I bought his book a while back. I'll tell you this in all honesty. If you are not taking Hsing-I from a teacher, then the book is worse than useless. However, I don't think that was his intention.

The book means something to me, due to actual lessons. It is just a reference as far as I am concerned, but I know what I am looking for. You absolutely could never come close to learning the five elements from his book, due to no proper explanation of the footwork involved. It is just too much to ask any book to teach the five elelments to any person with no teaching.

He does look good in the pictures. I see no reason that he would not have real power from his alignments.

[Water Dragon]

It's also a two way street. I know I refuse to by any products from anyone who flirts with the Qi Head crowd. If they can make all that money by advertising hype, why should they put their real skills on print or in video?

I wish more teachers would take Cartmell's approach. Low key down to earth, but everytime I read something from him, I'm thinking "Wow, I swear this guy must know my teachers. They say the same things."

He doesn't sell flash, and he doesn't put out higher level stuff, but what he puts out, I'll buy. And I'll also recommend it to anyone else wholeheartedly. I have no problems endorsing his material as IME, it's the real deal. Laid out in black and white.

I sometimes wonder how much good stuff I've passed over due to P.T. Barnum style advertising.

[fiercest tiger]

can i ask what he is doing with a water melon, is he slaping it?

ive seen erle and have been to his seminars, i didnt think much..nuff said!

[Internal Boxer]

FTiger

If you just stood with the crowd then I can understand but if you have crossed hands with him and ask him to demonstrate his power then you will be suprised

[dfedorko@mindspring.com]

The break I spoke of was in "Inside Kung Fu" magazine, July 1998. He is on the cover. The article, "Hands Like Stone in 100 Days" runs from pages 38 - 43. The picture I question is on page 40. His hand is in the watermelon. I do not think, using Physics, that the break can be done. Why would you do it in the first place?? I have seen watermelon with shuto and spear-hand broken a long time ago but nothing like the picture. Has any of you performed this break?? What was the outcome?? Again, I just lost a little respect for Sifu McNeil when I saw the picture in the magazine. But the fact remains that he is a good martial artist.

xiaotiema