Originally Posted by
SHemmati
** 2 things in these Liu's instructionals that seem much annoying to me:
first it is the shen fa (body movement/mechanics), and second the Quan pu (movement names). first, if you compare his 1st VCD with Deyang's Xiao Luohan, you know how bad is his shen fa, so that the Luohan postures of the form do not look like Luohan at all! second, if you compare his names list with the above-linked names for the 27 postures and the 36 movements of the form, you see throughout Liu's names, that some times he has counted two obviously different postures, like pics 17-3 and 17-4 of the book, as one, while he has sometimes assigned different numbers to consecutive transition movements! when one counts individual postures, there are 27, and when one counts all the movements, there are 36. but the numbers and the names in these Liu's resources have seemingly been assigned randomly.