My opinion in the clips in his VTM post on WCK evolution.

1. The Hong Kong WCK is a Ip Man Wing Chun.

2. The Red flag WCK is an evolution of Ip Man WCK . It is more likely a wing Chun 2000.

A, it has the ip man WCK slt signature where the snake part such as in YKS , SNake crane, yik kam where evolved.

B, even it claim to be related to Tan Sau Ng, Nothern Shaolin , And Tan Sau, there is No wck Tan Sau in this set at all but Tong kiu or Zhao yang of white crane of fujian which is present . How can a fujian white crane symbolic technic named Zhao yang comes from a Northern shaolin ?

C, it is very interesting that , the legend of Tan Sau Ng, how he is from northern shaolin, how he has a great tan sau is always mention. What one missed is that Tan Sau in WCK 1850 is a snake hand belongs to the snake reel. Check into those older lineages of red boat WCK one will this snake hand type called tan sau.

3, the black flag is a further evolution of the red flag. Importing fujianese art. It is more likely a 2010 WCK evolution.

Wing Chun 1850 has snake and crane in all red boat related lineages, be it in chan wah soon, yks, snake crane, kulo, yik kam.


I would say the three clips are a presentation of three Ip Man lineage WCK evolution instead of the evolution of red boat opera WCk.


http://ezine.kungfumagazine.com/foru...44&postcount=9