Originally Posted by
Pacman
lets forget about the pak sau chung choi debate. no one can prove anything, we can just speculate.
my main point is that yuen kay san's achievements are all documented and recorded by the chinese government. you can choose to believe what i said about SN and YM, either way there is no proof that things did or did not happen. im just sharing my knowledge, i understand if it upsets some people.
Originally Posted by
Pacman
lets forget about the pak sau chung choi debate. no one can prove anything, we can just speculate.
I guess your statement says it all. You are speculating. Why cant you accept the Ip Clan offering tea for a movie storyline and accept it like Yuen Jo Tong has.
As are the legends of leung jan and the legends of ip man, and your posts that speak of ip man, his family, yiu choi are all WRONG when we look at the written history recorded IN CHINA. It sounds like someone who is jealous of the fame of Ip man(can anyone dispute he is famous? or bruce lee) and is spreading rumours after they have passed on for 30 years
I have yet to see 1 article or 1 video of those things you mentioned. You would be more conviencing if you had even 1 mention somewhere. And you have no mention of the historical data, videos, chinese text I posted which reveal the holes of your statements about Ip Man's life in fatshan.
As for Yuen Kay San accomplisements being detailed by the chinese goverment I am going to get on it. Because I am a fan of his lineage and yiu choi, mainland china, well wingchun in general and I embrace the diversity. Its was their intepretation and with that, will lead generations to later develop themselves and maybe even better the art, if its possible
If you are looking to speak up for Yuen Kay San and family, I suggest you start from a position of respect and gratitude. That seems to be how these 3 heros of Yuen, Yiu and Ip are remembered in China and speaks of their deep ties.
If Ip man didnt leave to go to hongkong would half of the world even know what wingchun is, and some big parts are attributed to Bruce Lee of course.
Last edited by Shadow_warrior8; 08-19-2010 at 12:16 AM.
讲你不听,听你不明,明你不做,做你又做错,错你又不认,认你又不改,改你又不服,不服你又不讲;那你要我 怎么办?