In my opinion, there is more to this behavior than the ego of self promotion. I believe it to be a cultural phenomenon.
no that at all,we just informed (as well in a chinese post not translated) that WC has gone too far away from the original,and of course even from the sha wah son version
so we hinted things in order to help people to see more clearly in the teaching they are receiving
Just so it is clear where we stand with each other, please clarify whether you just called me a liar. If not, please clarify what you meant.
i
have just meant that the persons telling you that were exegarating,and had perhaps a commercial purpose
Again, irrelevant. Without establishing your credentials
i over-estimated the ability of abstraction and extrapolation of some to analyse these posts the right way. plus this is also due to my way to formulate it in english
, all you did was make an appeal to authority logical fallacy.
[COLOR="rgb(0, 191, 255)"]it wasnot the purpose, the truth has to come from somewere ,at least and i dont ask to say thanks for what was disclosed . but people want to have a defensive stance and not being open mind ,i dont mind
[/COLOR]
Finally, you reveal you still contain reasonable skepticism. I don't know if you realized the full extent of what you were previously saying without it: Yip Man was a lousy teacher.
t[COLOR="rgb(0, 191, 255)"]hats not the word to use,and this way to teach is part of the wing chun system and even part of the chinese culture in martial arts. one ,two perhaps three students to become depositaries of the style..
its too dangerous to open the more direct technics to too much people
[/COLOR]
(Yes, the proverbial "putting all your eggs in one basket" is a mark of a lousy Sifu. What if that student got hit by a bus? Hundreds of years of knowledge ends there.)
[COLOR="rgb(0, 191, 255)"]thats what happened to kwok fu students apparenly[/COLOR]
[LIST]
[*]You are demonstrably better Ving Tsun technician than your peers on the quorum.
[*]The technical aspects of your skill are consequentially different than your peers on the quorum.
[*]Your methodology of learning such skill cannot be found in most other methodology and/or other methodology cannot develop the same skill as easily and/or as correctly.
[*]You go beyond the Ving Tsun realm and are, in fact, a good Martial Artist[COLOR="rgb(0, 191, 255)"] i prefer to say the technics ,im using are goods[/COLOR]
You know, I have to admit: Part of why I'm proposing this is pure silly amusement. (I guess I haven't done something quite stupid enough with my time, money, and effort in a while.) But don't get me wrong: I am not proposing a challenge or a gauntlet (though this can be arranged too if you want). I am being sincere: I am proposing a free exchange of ideas with your peers. Moy Yat had respect for Ng Chan. As Moy Yat's student, I consider it sort of a duty to help give you the opportunity to prove such claims if I am able. Believe it or not, I want you to succeed.
So what do you say, Moshe? Up for some genuine ol' fashioned Martial fun in the Big Apple? If so, then contact me privately via this website's private messaging system
(this link) Send me a telephone number and the times when you can be reached so we can start working out details together.