Proved wrong?? We are ones using our system and testing it under pressure. I think my track record as a teacher is fine and is not under question. If you want to be proved right then post your fights or chi sao or training and then we can compare if you have any grounds to be in a position to be proved of anything.
If we look at the way you stand, turn, and move in LTWT, it's not similar to CSLWC or WSLVT. The latter two do these things in much the same way and don't agree with LTWT for the same reasons.
Probably because they know how to knock someone out, and it's not by keeping the head high, leaning back, and extending the fist out like this guy:Just as a counter to the question: why do we CSL WCK leaning forward and bending down the head at they lunge forward with a strike?
Why? Because you post these clips on a forum. A place where people talk.
But you don't want to give a detailed response when someone asks you questions?
"You can't even give your name lol I can't waste my time then."
And my name helps you explain something? Call me Beatrice, if you want. If you can answer the questions, why not do so?
Some criticize this as looking like a Western Boxing guard too, but nope. It's Chinese Boxing. They just don't understand Ving Tsun and want to constrain it to their man/wu, cookie cutter model of what the "style" should be regardless of who's using it. These people aren't fighters.
A girls name suits you
Just because I share a clip or post information in clips for people- doesn't mean I'm here to do a q & a. I'm happy to chat to people and also answer some question at times. But to explain to someone who is so far off track to what I do is a waste of my time.
@ Alan
Your Hidden clip show's delinking - something trained in the first Chi Sau section of LTWT. It's good stuff, but I don't know why you assume this can't be seen by others.
Your fixation on the minutiae of what we are doing wrong when using our method in combat is getting very boring. We have been more than accomodating with your anally retentive questioning. You ask, but don't give anything to give your critique any credibility. Show us your wing chun, your expression. It's very easy to do, I'm sure you have a mobile phone with filming capability or know someone who does and you could quickly get someone to film you sparring hard.
You can't expect people to keep going out of their way posting clips and replying to your questions when you give nothing back. The more you post the more you sound like an armchair quarterback who's never really tested his skills. Supply a clip then we can see where we are going wrong. I have a sneaky suspicion though that if you did supply a clip you wouldn't like the constructive criticism it might receive...
Wasn't meant to be a comparison, just saying people make uninformed criticisms all the time. But why would it matter?
What is the problem with them guarding like that? Wing Chun can only be applied from the one cooker cutter guard? We don't necessarily have to occupy the centerline in order to control or defend it. It's not a fighting style, but a fighting skill.
Concur with LFJ, controlling the centreline doesn't mean you have to physically occupy it. This is the sort of observation beginners make