Sinking. That is a wrong word

[Phenix]

As title,

People use the word " sinking" alots and more than alots.


From:
Weight sinking to feet, breathing sinking to Dan Dien..... goes on and on.....

IMHO, I don't belive a bit of all of these.
Thus, with all these "sinkings" intructions... have you see those give these good "sinking" achieved advance level..... themself?


The Word should be "settle" not Sinking.

It is just like when one place a class of mud water in a quite place and then the dust "sinking then at the end settle " naturally.

Make that change to settle in stead of to sink ,
and one will breath great and "root" great.
Trying to "sink" ? one just push a reverse gear.


it is about settle in all condition naturally. it is not about trying to become a Woodern Dummy and SINK into the ground

Believe it or not.

Your turn.

[kj]

Originally posted by Phenix
As title,

People use the word " sinking" alots and more that alots.

Weight sinking to feet, breathing sinking to Dan Dien.....

IMHO, I don't belive a bit of all of these.
Thus, with all these "sinkings" intructions... non comes achieved and advance level.....


The Word should be "settle" not Sinking. Make that change and one will breath great and "root" great. Trying to "sink" ? one just push a reverse gear.

Believe it or not.

Your turn.

Good point regarding the nuances of the words.

Still, words are just words, and I cannot say that one word is a right word and another word is wrong.

If a wrong word is used, but the right underlying idea is transmitted person to person, then the word has done its job no matter which word was used. A rose by any other name and all of that.

Sometimes we don't even need words to get the right idea across. The richest parts of communication are non-verbal. This is not merely my opinion, but what has been demonstrated through formal studies. So we are very poor in this medium.

Having said that, I still enjoy dickering over words, LOL. While not averse to the word "sink," I too far prefer the word "settle" both for its connotation and its numerous implications. So I personally agree with your distinction.

Regards,
- Kathy Jo

[old jong]

I like the word...Sit!
This way,I can look at a whole class and yell SIT !...It's fun!

[yuanfen]

Old Jong- did you mis-spell the word-to escape the censor?.

[old jong]

Yuanfen!!!!!!
The result would be relative to addiing a "T" to sink!...

[[Censored]]

Maybe I will put together an online translator, for "WC newspeak" -> "English":

Sink -> Settle
Heavy -> Light
Energy -> Force
Force -> Clumsiness
Root -> Height
Qi -> Yi
Yi -> "I have no idea what I'm talking about"

[Phenix]

Originally posted by [Censored]
Maybe I will put together an online translator, for "WC newspeak" -> "English":

Sink -> Settle
Heavy -> Light
Energy -> Force
Force -> Clumsiness
Root -> Height
Qi -> Yi
Yi -> "I have no idea what I'm talking about"

This simple:

Sink ---> let is naturally settle, just wait a little but not prolong it.
Heavy ---> that is the feeling of the opponents' should not be one's. one has to feel light
Energy ---> how much do we feel while walking in our body? we need to move our 100ib? 200lb body every steps....
Force --> local tensing
Qi --> smooth in breathing and motion
Yi--> attention and intention.

[Phenix]

KJ,

hahahaha,
Certainly, I am trying to stir my english up

But seriously, translation is a problem. especially, when the sifu though and we don't experience it or totally understood.

Like in the drive in, one order 3 coke and 2 pop corn. and we always has to make sure it is not 2 coke and 3 pop corn. those type of communication......

Chinese to chinese communication has been a problem since you see different of version of teaching..... Chinese to English even worst. but the only communication can close the gap is the Drive In style of repeating and feed back.....

[Grendel]

Originally posted by Phenix
KJ,

hahahaha,
Certainly, I am trying to stir my english up

But seriously, translation is a problem. especially, when the sifu though and we don't experience it or totally understood.

Like in the drive in, one order 3 coke and 2 pop corn. and we always has to make sure it is not 2 coke and 3 pop corn. those type of communication......

Chinese to chinese communication has been a problem since you see different of version of teaching..... Chinese to English even worst. but the only communication can close the gap is the Drive In style of repeating and feed back.....

May I have fries with that?

You're right. On the Internet, communication is difficult, but even with feedback, can we be sure that we're talking about the same kind of Coke and popcorn?

How do you train to be "light" as opposed to heavy? Is it never correct in your opinion to be substantial in one's horse?

Regards,

[Phenix]

Originally posted by Grendel



How do you train to be "light" as opposed to heavy?
Regards,

When we walk is it light or heavy? or just walk?

[whippinghand1]

Originally posted by Phenix
It is just like when one place a class of mud water in a quite place and then the dust "sinking then at the end settle " naturally.

For application purposes often "settling" is not enough.

it is not about trying to become a Woodern Dummy and SINK into the ground. Believe it or not.

Sometimes it is. Believe it or not.

[Phenix]

For application purposes often "settling" is not enough.


without even achieve settling. the rest is day dreaming.---HS



Sometimes it is. Believe it or not.

Certainly, that will become hard bow and no longer agile WCK. In additional, after 40 years old check up to see if the heart still function properly if training this way. doesn't matter about believe, no health no advance martial art. try it and see.. --Hs

[KPM]

Hendrik wrote:

The Word should be "settle" not Sinking.
It is just like when one place a class of mud water in a quite place and then the dust "sinking then at the end settle " naturally.

---I see what you are saying. But IMHO "sink" is a more generic term that would emcompass what you mean by the word "settle." "Settle" seems to imply a more passive activity, whereas "sink" can be either passive or active. Actively dropping the weight by bending the knees in order to apply a downward force is "sinking", but I don't think "settle" quite describes the activity properly.

Keith

[whippinghand1]

Originally posted by Phenix
Certainly, that will become hard bow and no longer agile WCK.

WCK no need be agile all time.

In additional, after 40 years old check up to see if the heart still function properly if training this way. doesn't matter about believe, no health no advance martial art. try it and see.. --Hs

Training what way....? Sorry not sure what you're saying here.

[Alpha Dog]

Originally posted by Phenix
Chinese to chinese communication has been a problem since you see different of version of teaching..... Chinese to English even worst.

And English to English the worstest!!