Originally Posted by
YiLiQuan1
And who would determine those? Would the same standards apply to Muay Thai that apply to Tie Cheese push-my-hands groups? Sorry to be so sarcastic, but the standardization you bring up belongs solely in the competitive venues... Otherwise training will devolve to the lowest, safest denominator (which would make my training pretty darn boring...).
First, I disagree with "forced" CPR training. "Strongly recommended" for responsible teachers, but not forced.
to be certified as a coach in judo, you MUST be cpr certified. If I recall correctly, you cannot run a club under the usja unless you have at least one coach, meaning at least one person with a cpr cert. Fitness centers that have MA classes sometimes require a cpr cert as well.
Naturally, the governing bodies would vary from art to art, no taiji and muay thai would not be regulated in the same way. But, that is not to say that they won't both require certifications of some sort.
Second, how do you design a fight training curriculum where nobody ever runs the risk of getting knocked around and/or injured? That's the whole point - learning to defend against an attack that would (not "could") injure you if you fail to deal with it appropriately.
that's not what he said. He said it should be centered around safety, not that nobody should ever get hurt. try this test - have students spar full contact, full speed and power - like they would in a ring - with no pads. Then try it with pads. Then try it with pads and only about 80% power, etc. note the injury level changes.
Here is another test. Full speed randori (judo sparring) on a hardwood or concrete floor. Then try it on mats. This is really just common sense...
That will, most likely, eliminate 99% of martial arts teachers starting out... MAists are notoriously poorly funded, and I doubt anyone first opening a school has the kind of ready cash to bleed out for things that are mostly unnecessary (and were unavailable during the "not-so-good ol' days" of yore).
why? the school doesn't have to provide the gear, just let students know what they must purchase. And in a contact school, such things are not unnecessary at all.
You sound like someone with an axe to grind. Martial arts isn't knitting class. People get hit, thrown, bumped, bruised, and occasionally they bleed on you. It happens. Either deal with it, find a way to cope, or quit and find someplace safer to spend your free time. Dangerous pastimes carry potentially dangerous consequences. If you aren't prepared to face them, you shouldn't play in the first place.
Just my 2 cents. Mileage may, and quite likely will, vary.
you can get hit, thrown and bruised up all you want - and you can do it with safety provisions. I find it somewhat ironic that a muay thai and judo guy is having this discussion, but knowing and seeing the damage that can be done on a mat and with pads, I also know the greater damage that can be done without them.
i'm nobody...i'm nobody. i'm a tramp, a bum, a hobo... a boxcar and a jug of wine... but i'm a straight razor if you get to close to me.
-Charles Manson
I will punch, kick, choke, throw or joint manipulate any nationality equally without predjudice.
- Shonie Carter