Xing Yi - 5 Element Fist and Linking
Long Story short, I've been cross training Xing Yi with a friend for ~2 months and recently just finished learning the 5 element fists (i think that's what it's called: pi, zuan, pao, beng, heng).
For the record, this isn't my primary art, but I have heard great things about the 5 element fist even to the point that some of the original famous fighters of XingYi only knew these fists and did not know the 12 animal forms (not sure how true this is though but i can def believe it). That said, I was wondering how different is the linking form from just knowing the 5 fists? Of course I realize that even my understanding of these 5 fists is very small and must grow, but is the "linking form" a "cut and paste" of these 5 fists in a certain order?
and for the sake of being more specific, i think i remember my friend saying that the XingYi we've been training is Shanxi Che style.
I practiced Xing Yi for a few years
I really enjoyed it. I learned the five elements and the twelve animals, but the twevle didn't really stick as I didn't train them for as long or as well. Xingyi really came alive for me when I started doing An Shen Pao (安身炮) the two-man drill form. Of course, I was doing that with Tony Chen, so it brought me up to speed pretty quickly. When he moved on, I couldn't sustain it sadly.
Here's the Xingyi DVD series we produced with Liang Shouyu, Helen Liang, Yang Chenhan and Tony Chen.
Xing Yi 5 Elements Fists
Xing Yi Twelve Animals Fist
Selection of Traditional Xing Yi Fist Forms
5 Elements Xingyi Staff & Spear
12 Animals Xingyi Staff & Spear
5 Elements Xingyi Sword
12 Animals Xingyi Sword
This is the exact curriculum that I trained in under Shifu Tony and I'm rather embarrassed to admit that I've let that all go. I could probably still recite the 5 Elements hand form, and often think I should recover that 5 Elements Sword because I really loved it, but I'm too lazy and have enough on my plate now with my Shaolin practice. :o I even wrote an article on it: Xingyi's Dadao: The Lost Legacy of the Big Blade Troop in our 2006 March/April issue.
otf is right. Xinyi and Xingyi are different. To make matters more confusing, I currently train Changhu Xinyi Men (长护心意门) which is a completely unrelated Songshan Shaolin form.